Abstract
We investigated the process parameters of the high temperature MOCVD (HT-MOCVD) numerical model for the AlN growth based on CFD simulation using orthogonal test design. It is believed that high temperature growth condition is favorable for improving efficiency and crystallization quality for AlN film, while the flow field in the HT-MOCVD reactor is closely related to the process parameters, which will affect the uniformity of the film. An independently developed conceptual HT-MOCVD reactor was established for the AlN growth to carry out the CFD simulation. To evaluate the role of the parameters systematically and efficiently on the growth uniformity, the process parameters based on CFD simulation were analyzed using orthogonal test design. The advantages of the range, matrix and variance methods were considered and the results were analyzed comprehensively and the optimal process parameters were obtained as follows, susceptor rotational speed 400 rpm, operating pressure 40 Torr, gas flow rate 50 slm, substrate temperature 1550 K.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
As a wide range of direct bandgap semiconductor material, aluminum nitride (AlN) has been extensively investigated due to its high piezoelectric coefficient and thermal conductivity, and excellent optical and mechanical properties etc1,2,3,4, which make it a promising candidate for bulk substrate, blue and ultraviolet photo-detectors and deep ultraviolet LED5,6,7,8,9. Generally, metal organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) is a typical and effective approach to the AlN film growth with TMAl/NH3 as the gas precursor10,11,12,13,14,15. At high growth temperature, AlN film can achieved high surface growth rate, and the resultant AlN crystal surface is atomically flat16. In recent years, some progress of high-quality LED research has been made in experiment, and fluid flow, heat transfer, mass transfer and chemical reactions during the AlN growth have received extensive attention17,18. The effects and mechanisms of varied temperature and pressure on chemical reaction pathways and rate were studied based on Grove theory19. The effects of flow rate on AlN growth rate was investigated by CFD simulation which found that the film growth rate increased with the increase of hydrogen flow rate20.
Traditional test methods would need a large number of experiments and analyses to obtain effective parametric research. Orthogonal test design is a multi-factor and multi-level multi-factor experimental research method, which is widely used to solve engineering application problems based on mathematical analysis21,22. In this paper, the optimal numerical simulation results can be obtained by the comprehensive optimization design of various parameters of multi-physical fields, a large amount of calculation data will be generated. The test points selected during the orthogonal test design are evenly distributed and uniformly comparable, which have strong representativeness and will meet the demand of comprehensive numerical simulation23,24. This study using an orthogonal test design to find out the best process conditions, the best test results, and gives the scheme of process optimization.
In this paper, the multi-physics fields and process parameters of AlN film growth by HT-MOCVD have been investigated by orthogonal test design. According to the factors and levels, an L16(44) orthogonal array is employed to quantify the multi-physics fields and process parameters. The influence of process parameters for the optimal film uniformity was analyzed by range, matrix and variance analysis, respectively.
Computation model and methods
Geometry description
Schematic diagram of a specific MOCVD reactor similar to the close-coupled showerhead (CCS) reactor is shown in Fig. 1a. The reactor consisted of the gas inlets, the chamber walls, the susceptor and the gas outlets. The gas inlets are used to transfer the group III metal organic precursors and group V gas hydrides carried by carrier gas (H2) into the reactor and the precursors gases pass through the chamber to participate in chemical reactions. The whole numerical simulation process is based on a three-dimensional model, which is divided into about one million grids as shown in Fig. 1b. The dimensions of the reactor are described in Fig. 1a which the height (Hs), the width of gas inlet (Din), the susceptor diameter (Ds), the outer wall diameter (Do) and the reactor height (Hr) are 8 mm, 2 mm, 183 mm, 256 mm and 57.8 mm, respectively. As the reaction chamber is a vertical spray structure. Mixing of gaseous reactants into the reaction chamber may cause the parasitic reactions and produce more complex pre-reactions. Finally, it will affect the uniformity of film deposition. In order to prevent the metallic organic gas source and ammonia from mixing immediately after entering the inlets, we used a zoned isolation device at the inlets. Isolation is done by using carrier gas, which is N2 and H2 the inert gas. After the gas source enters the reaction chamber, it will spread in a vertical direction alone under the action of the isolation gas until it is close to the high temperature area of the substrate and then fully mix and react. To a certain extent, the occurrence of parasitic reactions and partial waste of gas sources are avoided. The partition isolation device is shown in Fig. 2, in which area A is TMAl, area B is NH3, and area C is N2 and H2.
Orthogonal test design
The orthogonal test design that optimizing the multi-physics fields and process parameters of the AlN growth by HT-MOCVD was divided into several parts: selecting test objectives, evaluating indicators, selecting factors and levels, designing an appropriate orthogonal array, listing test plan and corresponding results, analyzing the test results through range, matrix and variance analysis, and finally finding the optimal combination of factors and levels.
During AlN growth by HT-MOCVD the reactants are TMAl, NH3, hydrogen and other gases, and the hydrodynamic behavior and flow field distribution in the reactor will affect the uniformity of the film. The hydrodynamic behavior is closely related to the (A) gas flow rate, (B) operating pressure, (C) substrate temperature, and (D) rotating speed of susceptor. As the test involves 4 degrees of freedom and the complex interaction among them, a large number of experiments are needed to find out the most stable flow field distribution and relatively optimal combination of process parameters.
In the design of orthogonal test, the core issue is to select and identify the factors that may affect the indicators. Therefore, taking no account of the interaction influence among these parameters, the factors can be considered as the variables which correspond to the four free parameters i.e. A, B, C, and D mentioned above. Level, also known as bit-level, corresponding to the factors represented different numerical simulation states. We should consider both the range of parameters and the number of levels to determine the level, so the factors were divided into four continuous levels to represent the variation range. Flow field and heat transfer in the reactor need to be considered and the continuous liquid level should be appropriated. The orthogonal factors and levels are shown in Table 1.
In this study, we have investigated four free parameters and each including four levels. The L16(44) orthogonal array was adopted to carry out the optimization combination test. Where L refers to orthogonal array, the 16 represents that the main array has sixteen rows, which indicates 16 cases designed by orthogonal array, the 4 represents that each investigated factors has four levels, and the 5 denotes that the test has five columns, which indicates five factors. As shown in Fig. 3, in order to analyze the influence of the four factors on the three indicators, 5 points on the substrate were selected according to the 5 point principle of wafer uniformity. The variance of the simulation results is calculated as
where xi is the data of one point, m is the average value of xi, and n is the number of data.
As shown in Table 2, the first column lists the numbers from 1 to 16, representing the 16 simulation cases. Columns 2 to 5 represent levels of different factors, i.e. A, B, C and D. Considering that the numerical simulation in this study involves four changing factors, the last column in the table is error evaluation, namely error term. In Table 1, each row in the table corresponds to a growth condition, where the numbers “1, 2, 3, 4” represent the different levels of each factor. For example, the 5th case corresponds to a combination of 2nd level of A, the 1st level of B, the 2ed level of C and the 3rd level of D. The right columns on the right side of the table list the indicators, namely the density variance, pressure variance, and temperature variance for each case. During this study the sixteen simulation cases were investigated using CFD numerical method and the results of the 14th case are shown in Figs. 4 and 5.
According to the design above, for any column, all four levels were participated and occur with the same frequency. Two columns contain any possible combination of levels and the occurrences are equal. Each layer of a factor is equal to the combination of factors of the other layers, indicating that the horizontal configuration between any two columns is consistent.
Results and discussion
Range analysis
Judging the order and optimal level of each factor by the average value of each factor based on the orthogonal test design. The judgment methods are as follows: (1) K1, K2, K3, K4 represent the average value of each factor at each level. By comparing the mean of the levels to determine the factors of the optimal level, the smaller the \(\overline{{K_{{\text{i}}} }}\), the smaller the variance of the experimental results, the better the uniformity caused by the case. (2) Range R = max {K1, K2, K3, K4} − min {K1, K2, K3, K4} indicates the influence of various factors. The large range indicates that the horizontal variation of this factor has a great influence on the experimental result which is the main factor. The range of error term indicates the error caused by the random. If the range of error term is large, an interaction between various factors exits. Through the simulation of 16 orthogonal test cases, the order of each factor and the optimal level of density distribution, pressure distribution and temperature distribution were obtained. As the Table 3 shows, the range of error term in the three indicators is smaller than that of other factors, indicating that the interaction among factors is weak. Therefore, the orthogonal test design is reasonable and there is no need for interactive design.
As the range of B (2.6395 × 10–10) > the range of D (2.0123 × 10–10) > the range of C (1.1939 × 10–10) > the range of A (9.9865 × 10–11), which affects the density distribution is B, D, C, A. Therefore, the optimal level combination of density distribution is B1–D1–C3–A2. Similarly, the optimal level combination of pressure distribution and temperature distribution is D1–A2–C4–B1 and C1–D3–A3–B2.
Matrix analysis
The order of the factors and the optimal level were judged by the range analysis, while the weight of each factor and level should be analyzed to determine the optimal combination using the matrix analysis. As the index layer, factor layer and level layer are the three-layer structural models of the orthogonal test, we defined 1, index layer matrix: including m factors, each factor is divided into n levels, and the average index of the j level of factor Ai is Kij. The surface of the film is expected to be uniform, and the matrix was
Definition 2, factor layer matrix, \(T_{{\text{i}}} { = }{1 \mathord{\left/ {\vphantom {1 {\sum\nolimits_{j = 1}^{{\text{n}}} {K_{{{\text{ij}}}} } }}} \right. \kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {\sum\nolimits_{j = 1}^{{\text{n}}} {K_{{{\text{ij}}}} } }}\), matrix T was established as
Definition 3, level layer matrix, the range of A1 is si, \(S_{{\text{i}}} { = }{{{\text{s}}_{i} } \mathord{\left/ {\vphantom {{{\text{s}}_{i} } {\sum\nolimits_{i = 1}^{m} {s_{i} } }}} \right. \kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {\sum\nolimits_{i = 1}^{m} {s_{i} } }}\), matrix S was established as
The range analysis method of multi-index orthogonal experiment is summarized.
Step 1 Find the K matrix, T matrix and S matrix of each factor, and then calculate the weight matrix ki (i = 1, …, m).
Step 2: Take the mean matrix of the m matrices \({{\sum\nolimits_{{{\text{i}} = 1}}^{{\text{m}}} {{\text{k}}_{{\text{i}}} } } \mathord{\left/ {\vphantom {{\sum\nolimits_{{{\text{i}} = 1}}^{{\text{m}}} {{\text{k}}_{{\text{i}}} } } {\text{m}}}} \right. \kern-\nulldelimiterspace} {\text{m}}}\) as follows
where \(A_{ij} \left( {i = 1 \cdots M,j = 1 \cdots N} \right)\) indicator values corresponding to the jth level of the first factor.
Step 3 According to the requirements of the test for each index, find out the level j corresponding to the maximum or minimum value of each Ai in the K matrix, regard it as the optimal level of the corresponding factors, and then find out the optimal level combination of all factors.
According to the above calculation steps, the weight matrix of the temperature distribution is calculated as follows
Similarly, the weight matrix K2 of the density distribution and the weight matrix K3 of the pressure distribution are calculated. Finally, the weight matrix which affects the index is obtained
Based on the above calculation and analysis, the optimum combination is D1–B1–A2–C3. The optimum process parameters for the AlN growth by HT-MOCVD are as follows, the susceptor rotational speed 400 rpm, the operating pressure 40 Torr, the gas flow rate 50 slm, the substrate temperature 1550 K.
Variance analysis
The matrix analysis method can obtain the optimum process parameters, while the cause of the difference of experiment results at different levels of factors is not clear. The analysis of variance can not only give an accurate estimate of the impact of each factor on the test results, but also provide a criterion to judge whether the effect of the factors examined is significant. We performed variance analysis and the results are shown in Table 4.
In the variance analysis of orthogonal test, the variance of error term is used as the estimation of test error. The formulas used in variance analysis are as follows
where S is the sum of deviation squares, K is the total number of factors, n is the total number of experiments, Ti is the sum of the data corresponding to level i, T is the sum of all experimental data, f is the degree of freedom of factors, V is the mean square, \(F_{\theta }\) is the ratio of F, Vf is the mean square of factors, and Vθ is the mean square of errors.
According to the theory of mathematical statistics, if \(F_{{\text{a}}}\) is greater than \(F_{\theta }\), it is considered that this factor has a significant effect on the results; if \(F_{{\text{a}}}\) is less than \(F_{\theta }\), it is considered that this factor has no significant effect on the results. As shown in Table 4, for density distribution, according to \(F_{\theta }\), the order of factors can be determined as B → D → C → A, in which the \(F_{\theta }\) of pressure is much larger than F0.05 (3,3), and the pressure factor is very significant; The pressure distribution is determined by \(F_{\theta }\) to determine the order of factors as D → A → C → B. The temperature distribution is determined by \(F_{\theta }\) to determine the order of factors as C → D → A → B. Through the evaluation of variance method, the optimal parameters obtained were verified, and the criterion to judge whether the effect of the factors examined is significant can provide theoretical guidance for optimization of process parameters during HT-MOCVD growth.
Conclusion
In this paper, an optimized multi-physical field numerical model was established for the AlN growth by high temperature MOCVD (HT-MOCVD) based on CFD simulation and the influences of the process parameters on the AlN growth uniformity were investigated carefully based on the orthogonal test design. Firstly, the orthogonal test design takes the susceptor rotational speed, operating pressure, gas flow rate, substrate temperature as factors, and the density field distribution, pressure field distribution, temperature field distribution as indicators. Then, the data of 5 points on the surface were extracted to quantify the film uniformity. Finally, the results were analyzed by range, matrix and variance methods considering the influence of process parameters on film uniformity. The optimum process parameters of this three-dimensional reactor for the AlN growth by HT-MOCVD were obtained as follows: the susceptor rotational speed 400 rpm, operating pressure 40 Torr, gas flow rate 50 slm, substrate temperature 1550 K.
Data availability
The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Abbreviations
- HT-MOCVD:
-
High temperature metal organic chemical vapor deposition
- CFD:
-
Computational fluid dynamics
- TMAl:
-
Trimethylaluminium
References
Kinoshita, T. et al. Appl. Phys. Express 8, 061003 (2015).
Inoue, S., Naoki, T., Kinoshita, T., Obata, T. & Yanagi, H. Light extraction enhancement of 265 nm deep-ultraviolet light-emitting diodes with over 90 mW output power via an AlN hybrid nanostructure. Appl. Phys. Lett. 106, 131104 (2015).
Faria, F. A. et al. Low temperature AlN growth by MBE and its application in HEMTs. J. Cryst. Growth 425, 133–137 (2015).
Taniyasu, Y., Kasu, M. & Makimoto, T. An aluminum nitride light- emitting diode with a wavelength of 210 nanometres. Nature 441, 325–328 (2006).
Lin, W. T., Meng, L., Chen, G. & Liu, H. Epitaxial growth of cubic AlN films on (100) and (111) silicon by pulsed laser ablation. Appl. Phys. Lett. 66, 2066 (1995).
Cheng, H. et al. AlN films deposited under various nitrogen concentrations by RF reactive sputtering. J. Cryst. Growth 254, 46 (2003).
Ristoscu, C., Ducu, C., Socol, G., Craciunoiu, F. & Mihailescu, I. N. Structural and optical characterization of AlN films growth by pulsed laser deposition. Appl. Surf. Sci. 248, 411 (2005).
Schowalter, L. J. et al. Epitaxial growth of AlN and Al0.5Ga0.5N layers on aluminum nitride substrates. J. Cryst. Growth 211, 78–81 (2000).
Ikenaga, M. et al. Quantum chemical study of gas-phase reactions of trimethylaluminium and triethylaluminium with ammonia in III–V nitride semiconductor crystal growth. J. Cryst. Growth 237(1), 936–941 (2002).
Mihopoulos, T. G., Gupta, V. & Jensen, K. F. A reaction-transport model for AlGaN MOVPE growth. J. Cryst. Growth 195(1–4), 733–739 (1998).
Ohba, Y., Yoshida, H. & Sato, R. Growth of high-quality AlN, GaN and AlGaN with atomically smooth surfaces on sapphire substrates. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 36, L1565 (1997).
Nakamura, K. et al. Quantum chemical study of parasitic reaction in III–V nitride semiconductor crystal growth. J. Organomet. Chem. 611(1), 514–524 (2000).
Creighton, J. R., Wang, G. T. & Coltrin, M. E. Fundamental chemistry and modeling of group-III nitride MOVPE. J. Cryst. Growth 298, 2–7 (2007).
Nakamura, K., Hirako, A. & Ohkawa, K. Analysis of pulsed injection of precursors in AlN-MOVPE growth by computational fluid simulation. Phys. Status Solidi C 7, 2268–2271 (2010).
Uchida, T., Kusakabe, K. & Ohkawa, K. Influence of polymer formation on metalorganic vapor-phase epitaxial growth of AlN. J. Cryst. Growth 304, 133–140 (2007).
Tsai, C. L. , Liu, H. H., Chen, J. W. et al. Improving the light output power of DUV-LED by introducing the intrinsic last quantum barrier interlayer on the high-quality AlN template, in International Symposium on Next-generation Electronics (IEEE, 2016).
Enslin, J. et al. Metamorphic Al0.5Ga0.5N: Si on AlN/sapphire for the growth of UVB LEDs. J. Cryst. Growth 464, 185–189 (2017).
Lee, B. R. et al. ITO/Ag/AlN/Al2O3 multilayer electrodes with conductive channels: application in ultraviolet light-emitting diodes. J. Alloy. Compd. 741, 21–27 (2018).
Pu, K. et al. A kinetics model for MOCVD deposition of AlN film based on Grove theory. J. Cryst. Growth 478, S0022024817304967 (2017).
Bao, Q. et al. Effect of hydrogen carrier gas on AlN and AlGaN growth in AMEC Prismo D-Blue MOCVD platform. J. Cryst. Growth 419, 52–56 (2015).
Zhang, Z. et al. Influencing factors of GaN growth uniformity through orthogonal test analysis. Appl. Therm. Eng. 91, 53–61 (2015).
**ang, P. et al. Orthogonal design for fabrication of ZnO thin films by MOCVD. Semicond. Optoelectron. 17(7), 23–25 (2008).
Liu, Y. W. et al. Parameter study of the injection configuration in a zero boil-off hydrogen storage tank using orthogonal test design. Appl. Therm. Eng. 109, 283–294 (2016).
Cui, W. et al. Investigation on process parameters of electrospinning system through orthogonal experimental design. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 103(5), 3105–3112 (2007).
Funding
The National Key R&D Program of China (Grant No. 2017YFB0404202), and the 111 Project (No. B12026).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
X.D. designed this project. J.A. performed the calculations, analyzed the calculated results and wrote the original manuscript. J.Z. checked the calculation results and modified the manuscript. L.F. modified the manuscript. All authors discussed the results and worked on the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher's note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
An, J., Dai, X., Feng, L. et al. Parameter study of the high temperature MOCVD numerical model for AlN growth using orthogonal test design. Sci Rep 11, 8877 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-87554-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-87554-8
- Springer Nature Limited