Abstract
Background
The most commonly used approach for distal radius fractures is the traditional Henry approach. However, it requires an intraoperative incision of the pronator quadratus (PQ) muscle, which results in a series of complications if the repair of the PQ fails.
Aim
The objective of this study was to investigate the efficacy of sparing the pronator quadratus for volar plating of the distal radius fractures.
Methods
Seventy-six patients who suffered from distal radius fractures of types 23-B, 23-C1, and 23-C2 as per the AO Foundation and Orthopaedic Trauma Association (AO/OTA) classification were treated with volar locking plate fixation using either the PQ muscle incision and repair (group A, n = 39) or the PQ muscle preservation approach (group B, n = 37). Intraoperative index, postoperative efficacy and complications of patients were recorded and evaluated.
Results
All patients were followed up for more than one year after surgery. All fractures achieved union. There were significant differences in mean operative time, mean intraoperative blood loss, and mean fracture healing time between the two groups. Still, there were no significant differences in limb function scores between the two groups at the 12-month postoperative follow-up. Outcomes assessed at 1 week, 1 month, and 3 months after surgery demonstrated significant differences in the mean range of motion and pain-related visual analog scale (VAS) between the two groups. As the range of motion and grip strength increased, the VAS scores decreased, and there was no significant difference between the two groups at 12 months postoperatively. Although tendon irritation and delayed carpal tunnel syndrome were more common in group A than in group B (7.6% vs. 0% and 5.1% vs. 0%, respectively), the differences were not statistically significant.
Conclusion
The modified Henry approach with sparing pronator quadratus muscle has no significant advantage in the range of wrist motion and upper limb function in the late stage. Nevertheless, the intraoperative placement of the plate under the pronator quadratus muscle can shorten the operation time, reduce intraoperative bleeding, reduce early postoperative pain, promote early activity, and improve the patient's quality of life. It is recommended that the pronator be preserved at the time of surgery.
Similar content being viewed by others
Background
Fractures of the distal radius are common and account for approximately 17% of fractures [1]. They are among the most common orthopedic injuries seen in the emergency room [2].This observation is partly due to increased life expectancy, leading to more osteoporotic fractures and an increasing variety of contact sports leading to high energy trauma in the younger population [3].
Volar locking plate fixation has become the standard surgical procedure for treating unstable distal radius fractures [4,5,6]. Johnson et al. [7] first reported the function of the pronator quadratus muscle to stabilize the distal ulnar radial joint in 1976. The most commonly used approach in distal radius fracture surgery is the traditional Henry approach, which requires slicing open the PQ muscle. There is great controversy regarding the significance of PQ muscle repair and whether the postoperative wrist function and outcomes are affected. Previous studies showed that even in patients with repaired PQ muscle [8], there is still a significant loss of strength in pronation after surgery, which may be related to tissue damage and edema or poor repair. Therefore, this study investigates the patient outcomes following intraoperative PQ muscle preservation with a posteriorly-placed plate.
Clinical data were collected from 76 patients with distal radius fractures who underwent open reduction and plate internal fixation. Patients were grouped based on whether the PQ muscle would be spared during the procedure or not. Intraoperative index, postoperative efficacy, and complications of the patients were evaluated. This retrospective comparative study aimed to investigate the effect of preserving the PQ muscle on wrist function in patients.
Methods
After the Institutional Review Board's written approval, a retrospective study was conducted between January 2019 and October 2020. 76 patients with distal radius fractures who underwent open reduction and plate internal fixation at the First Affiliated Hospital of **er D, Espen D, Gabl M. Complications following internal fixation of unstable distal radius fracture with a palmar locking-plate. J Orthop Trauma. 2007;21(5):316–22." href="#ref-CR32" id="ref-link-section-d123176637e1758">32,33,34]. This technique can diminish these complications since the PQ muscle protects the flexor tendon and allows space for tendon gliding.
Jung et al. [35] measured the anatomy of the cadaveric specimen with CT imaging and concluded that the distal fracture of the radius was fixed using a small incision approach. The distal fracture fragment was large enough to place the distal row of screws without opening the PQ muscle, and the plate was appropriately placed. The PQ muscle covering the implant's surface prevents risks such as tendon abrasion, which indicates that the role of the PQ muscle in sheathing the implant cannot be ignored.
Carpal tunnel syndrome is a severe complication after surgical treatment of distal radius fractures [36,37,38]. Kashir et al. [23] first described an approach for splitting the brachioradialis muscle. By following this approach, they concluded that the integrity of the PQ was preserved, and all distal radius fractures requiring a volar plating could be treated without further incision. They reported no nerve injury or subluxation. However, it was found that this approach involves the radial artery during surgery, and the latter is highly susceptible to damage. Chul ki Goorens et al. obtained satisfactory results with the Minimally Invasive Pronator Quadratus Sparing Approach (MIPO) for distal radius fractures. However, this technique is more demanding for the surgeon [39], and the incision used in the MIPO technology for distal radius fractures are adjacent to the median nerve throughout the operation, and unfamiliarity with the procedure, repeated pulling of the incision, and placement of screws during the surgery may easily irritate the median nerve and cause nerve injury. Therefore, it was believed that adequate surgical field exposure is a prerequisite to avoid complications [27, 29].
The typical anatomical structure of the PQ muscle is the basis of its function [40]. It was found that the PQ muscles were heavily scarred, significantly atrophied, and adhered to the surrounding tissue after suturing. Muscle function is mainly impaired due to the distortion of its anatomy. This impairment is probably due to the disruption of the blood supply from the radial artery to the muscle after the latter has been severed. Hence, affecting the healing of the muscles.
Moreover, the PQ muscle is also a vital blood supply to the periosteum, with its provision from the anterior interosseous artery and the PQ muscle branches of the radial and ulnar arteries, as well as the posterior interosseous artery playing a crucial role in the healing of distal radius fractures. In this study, the mean bone healing time in the sparing PQ group was 11 weeks, lower than the 12 weeks in the conventional incision group. In addition, PQ muscle is a brittle piece of muscle, which is challenging to suture and often tears apart after suturing. The local soft tissue tension increases significantly, especially after the insertion of the plate, making it difficult to pull the muscle together.
Many studies have been reported on the treatment of distal radius fractures with various sparing of the PQ muscle, most of which analyzed the patients' near future postoperative functional recovery of the wrist. However, there are fewer studies on the long-term forearm rotation angles. In this study, we compared the long-term postoperative forearm and wrist function between two groups of patients with or without complete preservation of the anterior rotator muscle, and also focused on the postoperative pain scores of the patients. Satisfactory fracture reduction and good wrist function can be obtained with the palmar approach no matter whether the PQ muscle is preserved or not. Improved patient outcomes are observed when the respective surgical indications are mastered, and the articular surface reduction is adequate. However, preserving the PQ muscle to rehabilitate the forearm rotation is more advantageous in the short term.
It was previously believed that the PQ muscle was less critical, and that the anterior rotator function was limited; however, this is not the case. Jesper Sonntag et al. [41] concluded in a study that with or without repair of the PQ muscle after incision, ultrasound results showed that both were shorter than the healthy side. Still, the shortening was more significant in the unrepaired group. The function of the PQ muscle depends on its normal structure, and it is believed that incision of the PQ muscle with or without repair produces scarring that further affects forearm rotation function. Early forearm rotation is likely to cause a re-tear of the PQ muscle, leading to poor forearm function recovery. Therefore, it is recommended to avoid excessive forearm rotation for 3 weeks after surgery and wait for the scar repair of the PQ muscle to stabilize before active exercise, which is one of the reasons for the poor recovery of early forearm rotation. Nevertheless, it does not mean that the forearm rotation function is significantly limited at the later stage when the PQ muscle is dissected intraoperatively. This study showed no significant difference in the ROM of forearm rotation between the two groups at 12 months postoperatively. Hence, the sparing of the PQ muscle intraoperatively did not demonstrate a significant advantage in the long-term forearm rotation function. However, performing PQ muscle preservation is strongly recommended as it decreases the risk of muscle re-tear in rehabilitation, dramatically reduces the patient's pain, and encourages exercise.
In this surgical technique, it was found that bleeding before skin closure and after the release of the tourniquet were often minimal and sometimes did not even require any postoperative drainage system. It can be explained by the intact PQ muscle and by the cushioning effect of the muscle on the volar plate. The short duration of the procedure significantly decreases the risk of iatrogenic infection.
The AO classification and Fernandez classification are used to classify distal radius fractures, and the AO classification is more popular to guide treatment and determine prognosis. This study included the AO classification of distal radius fractures type B and C1 and C2. In addition, all types of fractures of the distal radius are generally treatable with a volar plate. However, in the case of type A fractures of extra-articular fractures, in order to avoid disruption of the blood supply and to reduce the burden of surgery on the patient, type A fractures are recommended to be treated with manual reduction and plaster fixation or external fixation combined with Kirschner wire since the fracture line is located at the level of the PQ muscle and the PQ muscle itself is a partial injury preoperatively. For comminuted fractures, a fragment-specific plate can be used for fixation.
Furthermore, the following data were collected from the surgical technique of PQ muscle locking plate preservation in the treatment of distal radius fractures. (1) The distal incision should not exceed the watershed line of the distal radius. Traumatic arthritis causes severe discomfort. (2) For dorsally displaced fracture blocks, especially AO fracture type B, reduction and fixation may be assisted by Kirschner wire or small dorsal incisions. (3) Intraoperative temporary fixation of Kirschner wire should be removed promptly after the insertion of 3–4 locking screws to avoid interfering with the implantation of other screws. (4) The implanted screws should not be too long to prevent damage to the dorsal extensor tendon. The ‘carpal shoot-through view’ can be used to determine whether the screws fixing the metaphysis have penetrated the carpal joint cavity [42]. (5) Repeated muscle traction during the procedure should be avoided to prevent secondary injury to nerves, blood vessels, and tendons. (6) Maintaining the wrist in the flexed position during the procedure facilitates reduction and fixation. (7) This approach does not reveal the carpal cavity, and further management of the cavity requires a combination of arthroscopic carpal techniques. (8) A possible drawback of sparing the pronator quadratus is the same as that of MIPO [39], both of which lack direct visualization of the fracture reduction. If intraoperative exposure and fixation reduction are problematic, traditional surgical fixation should be chosen as soon as possible.
With the development of the modern economy and the increasing aging population, the proportion of distal radius fractures presenting in an emergency is high; and people's demand for quality of life is increasing. The collective goal that doctors and patients pursue is achieving optimal recovery, reducing pain, and returning to society early with minimal trauma and tissue damage. In this study, the efficacy of sparing the PQ muscle in treating unstable distal radius fractures was investigated. It concluded that sparing the PQ muscle with a modified Henry approach is feasible for treating intra-articular fractures. The physiological structure of the PQ muscle is preserved, and the contact between the plate and the tendon and nerve is better isolated, which avoids stimulation of the nerve and tendon and reduces the possibility of tendon abrasion. Furthermore, the risk of tissue bleeding and edema after incision of the PQ muscle and eventually adhesions with the surrounding tissue is avoided. The disadvantage is that sparing the PQ muscle may complicate fracture reduction. It then requires fixation with the aid of multiple Kirschner wires or a small dorsal incision. It is not very operable for AO-type C3 distal radius fractures with serious comminution.
Several limitations existed in this study. First, its retrospective study design and the possibility of selection bias. Second, this was a single-center study that enrolled only a small number of patients. High-quality randomized controlled trials with a larger sample size are still needed to reinforce these results. Third, this study did not include distal radius C3 type fracture cases. A larger sample size containing more fracture patterns would be helpful in a future study.
Conclusion
The modified Henry approach with sparing pronator quadratus muscle has no significant advantage in the range of wrist motion and upper limb function in the long term. However, the intraoperative placement of the plate under the pronator quadratus muscle can shorten the operation time, reduce intraoperative bleeding, may reduce early postoperative pain, promote early activity, and improve patients' quality of life. It is recommended that the pronator be preserved at the time of surgery.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Abbreviations
- PQ:
-
Pronator quadratus
- FCR:
-
The flexor carpi radialis
- VAS:
-
The visual analogue scale scores
- MIPO:
-
Minimally Invasive Plate Osteosynthesis
- ROM:
-
Range of movement
References
Via GG, Roebke AJ, Julka A. Dorsal Approach for Dorsal Impaction Distal Radius Fracture—Visualization, Reduction, and Fixation Made Simple. J Orthop Trauma. 2020;34:S15–6.
Chung KC, Spilson SV. The frequency and epidemiology of hand and forearm fractures in the United States. J hand surg. 2001;26(5):908–15.
Smith DW, Henry MH. Volar fixed-angle plating of the distal radius. JAAOS-J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2005;13(1):28–36.
Quadlbauer S, Pezzei C, Jurkowitsch J, Rosenauer R, Pichler A, Schättin S, Hausner T, Leixnering M. Early complications and radiological outcome after distal radius fractures stabilized by volar angular stable locking plate. Arch Orthop Traum Su. 2018;138(12):1773–82.
Plant CE, Parsons NR, Costa ML. Do radiological and functional outcomes correlate for fractures of the distal radius? Bone Joint J. 2017;99(3):376–82.
Pang EQ, Truntzer J, Baker L, Harris A, Gardner MJ, Kamal RN. Cost minimization analysis of the treatment of distal radial fractures in the elderly. Bone Joint J. 2018;100(2):205–11.
Johnson RK, Shrewsbury MM. The pronator quadratus in motions and in stabilization of the radius and ulna at the distal radioulnar joint. J hand Surg. 1976;1(3):205–9.
Armangil M, Bezirgan U, Başarır K, Bilen G, Demirtaş M, Bilgin SS. The pronator quadratus muscle after plating of distal radius fractures: is the muscle still working? Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2014;24(3):335–9.
Chloros GD, Papadonikolakis A, Ginn S, Wiesler ER. Pronator quadratus space and compartment syndrome after low-energy fracture of the distal radius: a case report. J Surg Orthop Adv. 2008;17(2):102.
Berglund LM, Messer TM. Complications of volar plate fixation for managing distal radius fractures. JAAOS-J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2009;17(6):369–77.
Hershman SH, Immerman I, Bechtel C, Lekic N, Paksima N, Egol KA. The effects of pronator quadratus repair on outcomes after volar plating of distal radius fractures. J Orthop Trauma. 2013;27(3):130–3.
Mulders MA, Walenkamp MM, Bos FJ, Schep NW, Goslings JC. Repair of the pronator quadratus after volar plate fixation in distal radius fractures: a systematic review. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr. 2017;12(3):181–8.
Kim JK, Park JS, Shin SJ, Bae H, Kim S. The effect of brachioradialis release during distal radius fracture fixation on elbow flexion strength and wrist function. J Hand Surg. 2014;39(11):2246–50.
Häberle S, Sandmann GH, Deiler S, Kraus TM, Fensky F, Torsiglieri T, Rondak I, Biberthaler P, Stöckle U, Siebenlist S. Pronator quadratus repair after volar plating of distal radius fractures or not? Results of a prospective randomized trial. Eur J Med Res. 2015;20(1):1–8.
Goorens CK, De Keyzer PB, Van Royen K, Provyn S, Goubau JF. Pronator quadratus repair after volar plate fixation in distal radial fractures: evaluation of the clinical and functional outcome and of the protective role on the flexor tendons—a randomized controlled study. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2021;31(3):541–8.
Feeney MS, Wentorf F, Putnam MD. Simulation of altered excursion of the pronator quadratus. J wrist surg. 2014;3(03):198–202.
Nho J, Gong HS, Song CH, Wi SM, Lee YH, Baek GH. Examination of the pronator quadratus muscle during hardware removal procedures after volar plating for distal radius fractures. Clin Orthop Surg. 2014;6(3):267–72.
Shi F, Ren L. Is pronator quadratus repair necessary to improve outcomes after volar plate fixation of distal radius fractures? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2020;106(8):1627–35.
Lu C, Liu W, Chang C, Shih C, Fu Y, Jupiter JB. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the pronator quadratus repair following volar plating of distal radius fractures. J Orthop Surg Res. 2020;15(1):1–9.
Bertelli JA, Ghizoni MF. Reconstruction of C5 and C6 brachial plexus avulsion injury by multiple nerve transfers: spinal accessory to suprascapular, ulnar fascicles to biceps branch, and triceps long or lateral head branch to axillary nerve. J Hand Surg. 2004;29(1):131–9.
Swigart CR, Badon MA, Bruegel VL, Dodds SD. Assessment of pronator quadratus repair integrity following volar plate fixation for distal radius fractures: a prospective clinical cohort study. J Hand Surg. 2012;37(9):1868–73.
Hohendorff B, Unglaub F, Spies CK, Müller LP, Ries C. Refixierung des musculus pronator quadratus mit einem Teil des M.-brachioradialis-Ansatzes bei der palmaren Plattenosteosynthese einer distalen Radiusfraktur. Oper Orthop und Traumatol. 2020;32(1):82–6.
Kashir A, Donnell T. A brachioradialis splitting approach sparing the pronator quadratus for volar plating of the distal radius. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg. 2015;19(4):176–81.
Dos Remedios C, Nebout J, Benlarbi H, Caremier E, Sam-Wing J, Beya R. Préservation du muscle carré pronateur dans les ostéosynthèses des fractures de l’extrémité distale du radius par plaque palmaire verrouillée. Technique chirurgicale Chir Main. 2009;28(4):224–9.
Heidari N, Clement H, Kosuge D, Grechenig W, Tesch NP, Weinberg AM. Is sparing the pronator quadratus muscle possible in volar plating of the distal radius? J Hand Surg (Eur Vol). 2012;37(5):402–6.
Liverneaux PA. The minimally invasive approach for distal radius fractures and malunions. J Hand Surg (Eur Vol). 2018;43(2):121–30.
Liverneaux P, Ichihara S, Facca S, Diaz JH. Résultats de l’ostéosynthèse par plaque antérieure et abord mini-invasif (MIPO) des fractures de l’extrémité distale du radius: mise au point. Hand Surg Rehabil. 2016;35:S80–5.
Rey P, Rochet S, Loisel F, Obert L. how to spare the pronator quadratus during MIPO of distal radius fractures by using a mini-volar plate. Chir Main. 2014;33(2):95–9.
Salgarello M, Visconti G, Barone-Adesi L. Interlocking circumareolar suture with undyed polyamide thread: a personal experience. Aesthet Plast Surg. 2013;37(5):1061–2.
Huang H, Wang J, Chang M. Repair of pronator quadratus with partial muscle split and distal transfer for volar plating of distal radius fractures. J Hand Surg. 2017;42(11):931–5.
Ruchelsman DE, Klugman JA, Madan SS, Chorney GS. Anterior dislocation of the radial head with fractures of the olecranon and radial neck in a young child: a Monteggia equivalent fracture-dislocation variant. J Orthop Trauma. 2005;19(6):428–31.
Arora R, Lutz M, Hennerbichler A, Krap**er D, Espen D, Gabl M. Complications following internal fixation of unstable distal radius fracture with a palmar locking-plate. J Orthop Trauma. 2007;21(5):316–22.
Duncan SF, Weiland AJ. Delayed rupture of the flexor pollicis longus tendon after routine volar placement of a T-plate on the distal radius. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF ORTHOPEDICS-BELLE MEAD-. 2007;36(12):669.
Rampoldi M, Marsico S. Complications of volar plating of distal radius fractures. Acta Orthop Belg. 2007;73(6):714.
Jung G, Cho C, Kim J. Anatomical study of the pronator quadratus muscle and comparison to fracture sites of the distal radius. Journal of the Korean Orthopaedic Association. 2012;47(1):48–53.
Gradl G, Mielsch N, Wendt M, Falk S, Mittlmeier T, Gierer P, Gradl G. Intramedullary nail versus volar plate fixation of extra-articular distal radius fractures. Two year results of a prospective randomized trial. Injury. 2014;45:S3–8.
Gradl G, Falk S, Mittlmeier T, Wendt M, Mielsch N, Gradl G. Fixation of intra-articular fractures of the distal radius using intramedullary nailing: a randomized trial versus palmar locking plates. Injury. 2016;47:S25–30.
Pierrart J, Tordjman D, Ikeuchi N, Delgrande D, Gregory T, Masmejean E. Lésions nerveuses associées aux fractures de l’extrémité distale du radius. Hand Surgery and Rehabilitation. 2016;35:S75–9.
Ki Goorens C, Debaenst N, Van Royen K, Provyn S, Goubau JF. Minimally Invasive Pronator Quadratus Sparing Approach versus Extended Flexor Carpi Radialis Approach with Pronator Quadratus Repair for Volar Plating in Distal Radial Fractures. Journal of Wrist Surgery. 2022;11(01):41–7.
Fang K, Lin X, Liu X, Ke Q, Shi S, Dai Z. Do we need to suture the pronator quadratus muscle when we do open reduction and internal fixation for fracture of the distal radius. Bmc Musculoskel Dis. 2020;21(1):1–7.
Sonntag J, Hern J, Woythal L, Branner U, Lange KH, Brorson S. The Pronator quadratus muscle after Volar plating: ultrasound evaluation of anatomical changes correlated to patient-reported clinical outcome. Hand. 2021;16(1):32–7.
Marsland D, Hobbs CM, Sauvé PS. Volar locking plate fixation of distal radius fractures: use of an intra-operative ‘carpal shoot through’view to identify dorsal compartment and distal radioulnar joint screw penetration. Hand. 2014;9(4):516–21.
Acknowledgements
Not applicable.
Disclosure
The authors report no proprietary or commercial interest in any product mentioned or concept discussed in this article.
Funding
This study was not funded by any foundation.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
XH: Conducted the study. Collected, analyzed, and interpreted the data. Wrote the manuscript. QJ: Designed the study, and interpreted the data, and edited the manuscript. HL: Planned the project. Interpreted the data. EK: Interpreted the data. CP: Interpreted the data. WK: Edited the manuscript, reviewed the manuscript. MT: Edited the manuscript, reviewed the manuscript. YH: Edited the manuscript. DF: Edited the manuscript. YZ: Planned the project. Reviewed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This retrospective study was approved by the Ethics Committee of The First Affiliated Hospital of **njiang Medical University and carried out in accordance with the ethical standards set out in the Helsinki Declaration. Informed consent was received from all participating.
Consent for publication
Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for publication of this case report and any accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the Editor of this journal.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
About this article
Cite this article
Huang, X., Jia, Q., Li, H. et al. Evaluation of sparing the pronator quadratus for volar plating of distal radius fractures: a retrospective clinical study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 23, 625 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-022-05576-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-022-05576-3