Abstract
The paper presents an improved analytical model for axial-flux eddy-current couplings with permanent magnets. The design procedure is based on the torque formula derived from a two-dimensional approximation of the magnetic field distribution. The developed model takes into account the heating of the copper disk and magnets due to the high slip speed. Another advantage of the developed model is the reduction in computation time compared to 3-D finite element simulations. The model is validated experimentally. A correlation between the model and the experiment is obtained. The coupling torque is subject to reduction due to low manufacturing accuracy. The model is effective for engineering use at the design stage of magnet couplings, especially for cable drums of cranes.
Article highlights
-
An improved analytical model for magnet couplings combined with a stop is developed and experimentally validated.
-
The analytical calculation of convective heat transfer combined with numerical calculation using the FEM makes it possible to solve the problem of the cooling design of the coupling.
-
The experiment study of the coupling design shows the in uence of manufacturing accuracy on the torque.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
1 Introduction
A large number of coupling designs are available for torque transmission. For non-contact torque transmission, magnetic couplings are used, which use the force of a magnetic field. The use of magnetic couplings is effective in cable drums of cranes [1].
In cable drums, it is necessary to prevent cable breakage in case of unexpected cable snagging on objects while winding on the drum. This task is accomplished precisely because there is no rigid connection between the engine and the drum. This is the relevance of their use.
However, in addition to torque transfer, stop** when the equipment is turned off is also required. The non-contact transfer of stop** torque also prevents cable breakage in case of emergency. This paper deals with the method of calculating the parameters of a magnetic coupling with the presence of a stop and its experimental validation.
Many books and articles are devoted to the problems of modeling [2,3,4,5], designing [6,7,8] and heating [9,10,11] of magnetic couplings. In the rest of this section, we will consider some related works.
Many books and articles are devoted to the problems of optimizing magnetic couplings. A full mathematical model is described in [12]. The calculation method described in the article is difficult to use in engineering practice. Calculation methods based on FEM [13, 14] allow to achieve high accuracy of the results, but they are labor-intensive at the initial stages of the design procedure. To achieve a compromise between the complexity, accuracy, and difficulty of calculations, it is convenient to use approximate analytical methods.
A coupling consisting of a copper disk and a disk with permanent magnets were described in [15]. Its torque function was obtained and validated experimentally. Due to the presence of slip, the copper part heats up and loses its conductivity. The torque function takes these losses into account, however, it does not take into account the heating of the magnets and the losses in their magnetic properties.
The design and mathematical model of coupling cooling are presented in [16]. However, it does not take into account the real design features or the presence of radiant heat transfer and thermal conductivity of parts. In this paper, the cooling model is refined and experimentally validated. The resulting mathematical model is convenient for engineering use and requires no additional expensive software.
In [17], a mathematical model of the stop is proposed, but it does not take into account the different values of the torque at different polarities of the magnets.
All the above-mentioned articles ignore the cost of making the coupling and the actual operating conditions. The problem of large heating and efficient cooling significantly increases the cost of design. And it is necessary to revise existing calculation methods for practical application in mechanical engineering.
Moreover, there is a need to combine both the coupling and the stop inside one design. The mutual influence of the stop on the working part of the coupling is theoretically absent, but it is necessary to check when working in real operation. There are no articles on the study of the joint operation of the coupling and the stop.
The purpose of the work is an experimental study of the magnetic coupling combined with a stop in real working conditions, verification, and validation of the developed mathematical model of torque and cooling. The model developed model should be effective for engineering use at the design stage of magnet couplings, especially for cable drums of cranes.
The paper is organized as follows. First, we describe the design of the coupling, its working conditions, and technological limitations. Then we proceed to the description of the mathematical model of the coupling and stop operation, the model of convective cooling. The original model has been refined. In the next section, we describe the experimental setup and make a plan for the experimental validation. In the last part, we present the results of the experiment. The correlation between the model and the experiment and the correction factor are obtained.
2 Design and working conditions
In this section we describe design and working conditions of the resulting coupling. Description of technical and technological problems and cooling problem are presented here. A sketch of the coupling combined with the stop is shown in Fig. 1. The coupling parameters are shown in Fig. 2. The coupling consists of a copper disk (1), an impeller (2), a stop consisting of two disks (5,6) with permanent magnets (3,4), a rotating housing with cooling fins (7).
The input shaft of the engine rotates the working part of the coupling with a copper disc, housing, and impeller, as well as with a stop disc. The rotating copper disc interacting with fixed permanent magnets creates a torque that exceeds the stop torque.
The flux linkage of the permanent magnets in the disks (5,6) creates a stop** torque. The stop** torque holds the cable drum when the equipment is not in operation.
The impeller and housing provide efficient cooling of the coupling at high slip. Its production is carried out on CNC machines. It is necessary to ensure a minimum radial run-out between the copper disc (1) and the disc with magnets (4). As it will be shown below, radial run out with a small gap significantly affects the torque.
3 Mathematical modeling
In this paper, we use a mathematical model based on Maxwell theory to design the coupling. Rotating permanent magnets create an eddy magnetic field that crosses the copper disk. At the same time, an induced EMF arises in the disk, which causes eddy currents in the copper plate. As a result, there is a conjugation of flows that leads to a system of partial differential equations, the solution of which can be performed in cylindrical coordinates using Bessel functions [5]. However, the articles [10, 18] state that the edge effects are insignificant and it is possible to reduce the problem to a linear three-dimensional one in Cartesian coordinates.
To find the coupling torque we use Eq. (1) proposed by [11]. The author [11] used Governing field equations and showed a detailed derivation of the coupling torque equation. Equation (1) reflects the dependencies on the geometric characteristics of the coupling and its parts, as well as on the properties of the material. The equations take into account the change in conductivity properties of copper and magnets when heated.
To calculate the torque, we introduced a number of assumptions. Both induced current losses and eddy losses at high slip values are not taken into account. During experimental study, a correction factor was obtained that takes into account the above losses.
where p is number of poles, \(\sigma \) is electrical conductivity of the copper, \(B_r\) is remanence of the permanent magnets, \(\varOmega \) is the slip speed, and \({\varTheta }\) is the temperature of material.
The magnets of the stop are axially magnetized. Through magnetic interaction, the torque applied to one disc is transferred through an air-gap to the other disc. To find the stop torque we use the mathematical model proposed by [17]. The author [17] reduced 3-D problem to 2-D problem, which makes the axial magnetic coupling equivalent to a linear magnetic coupling. He developed simple formulas for the axial and tangential components of the flux density in the air gap. The stop torque for direct polarity is calculated by Eq. (2).
According to the Eq. (2), the main dimensions of the coupling are determined. The next task is the constructive provision of cooling.
As a result of a high slip during the operation of the coupling, a high thermal power occurs. The thermal power is assumed to be equal to \(P\,=\,T_e \varOmega \), the heat flow is distributed to the surface of the copper disk.
Convective and radiant heat transfer occurs during operation. Part of the heat is transferred to the housing and the engine through the contact of parts. Analytical calculation of the transient problem is impossible. Numerical calculation and accounting of all these factors are labor-intensive [19,20,21]. Therefore, we describe steady-state problem.
The surface temperature of the coupling is calculated according to Eq. (3) proposed by [22]. The thermal power is calculated according to the torque calculated equation by Eq. (1), that takes into account that there is no change of conductivity of copper and magnets during heating. Therefore, the torque calculation must be performed sequentially. According to the obtained temperature, the conductivity of copper and magnetization of magnets are recalculated as functions of slip.
In Eq. (3), \(P_J\) is the thermal power, \(a_1\) is coefficient of forced convection [22], \(c_p\) is specific heat capacity, \(\mu \) is dynamic viscosity, and \(\kappa \) is specific thermal conductivity.
We solved the problem by the iterative approach. At the first step we calculated the temperature of the copper disk and magnets for a higher torque without taking into account losses of the properties. At the second step we used Eq. (3) to find the temperature. At the third step the values of electrical conductivity of the copper and remanence of the permanent magnets due to higher temperature were obtained and substituted in Eq. (1)
The results of the analytical calculation of the surface temperature of the coupling are shown in Fig. 3.
To calculate the temperature, it is necessary to take into account the cooling of the coupling surface by the airflow generated by the rotation of the impellers of the coupling itself, i.e. there is a process of forced convection. To determine the factors affecting the efficiency of convective heat transfer, we use the thermal similarity criterion. In this case, with convective heat transfer of the airflow and coupling surface with a guaranteed turbulent flow \((Re >10^4)\), the criterion of thermal similarity is Nusselt coefficients (Nu).
The torque function on the output shaft of the coupling without considering the heating effect (T) and considering the heating effect of the copper part and magnets (\(T^*\)) is shown in the Fig. 5. The stop torque is shown in Fig. 4. The temperature dependence on the slip is shown in Fig. 5. A temperature of 112 °C was calculated for slip \(\varOmega\, =\,2160\) rpm. According to the calculated convective heat transfer coefficient, a verification FEM temperature calculation and magnetostatic calculation was performed in ANSYS Mechanical. To provide the FEM temperature calculation, we use the following assumptions:
-
1.
Steady-state conditions.
-
2.
Radiant heat transfer is negligible compared to the convective and thermal conductivity of parts.
-
3.
The temperature on the input shaft of the electric motor is constant.
-
4.
The air temperature at the surface is constant.
Using the above formulas, we determine the main dimensions of the coupling. The next task was the constructive provision of cooling.
The calculation results are shown in Figs. 6 and 7. The surface temperature of the copper disk was 129 °C, i.e. the difference between numerical and analytical solutions is 15%. Figure 5 shows the comparison of torques without heating (T) and with heating (\(T^*\)). The maximum stop torque was 0.85 Nm, i.e. the difference between numerical and analytical solutions is 7%.
4 Experiment plan
Two experiments were designed for the experimental study of magnetic coupling: a two-factor experiment and a one-factor experiment. The factors were assumed to be linear and independent. The variable factors were the gap in the working part of the coupling, the rotation speed of the electric motor, and the gap between the magnets in the stop. The controllable factor was the coupling torque. The test in real working conditions was also carried out. A sketch of the experimental setup is shown in Fig. 8.
The complex of laboratory setup included a magnetic coupling and a drive based on an asynchronous motor, controlled by frequency converter FC-301 P4K0T4E20H2 (Danfoss), the coupling was rigidly fixed on the motor shaft.
The converter was controlled from remote control on the stand, where rotation speed signals were generated using buttons that simulate various operating modes. Braking of the asynchronous motor was carried out by free run-out.
The frequency converter control module, connected to the USB 2.0 bus of the computer allows observing and registering the variable parameters of the electric drive (actual motor speed, preset value of the motor rotation speed, actual current, preset value of current, shaft load torque).
5 Results of the experimental study
To validate the developed methodology, we tested the designed coupling for three values of gaps. In all tests, we observed lower torques compared to the calculated ones. The average relative difference was 0.75, but the type of dependence corresponded to the theoretical one. The experiment showed that the accuracy of making the parts to ensure the constancy of the gap has a significant impact on the torque. According to the results of the calculations using a mathematical model, the difference in torque at 2100 rpm was 19%.
When the gap is small, the mathematical model shows greater sensitivity of the torque to the input parameters. At a gap of 2 mm or less, the coupling behavior be- comes less predictable.
Based on the results of the experiment, a regression equation was compiled for the coupling under study:
where c is the gap, n is the slip speed.
The graphs of the obtained dependencies are shown in Fig. 9. The obtained model correlation confirms the possibility of using the model with a correction factor of 0.75. The difference in torque does not depend on the gap, speed of rotation, assembly process and is is inherent in the design or materials. The stop has no effect on torque.
5.1 Checking the stop torque
The operation of the coupling was tested in the parking stop mode. The results are shown in Fig. 10. The stop torque was 10% higher than the calculated one. The mathematical model of the stop is adequate to the real one. The stop magnets do not affect the operation of the coupling.
6 Discussions
It should be noted that the production cost of this type of magnetic coupling remains high. Ensuring manufacturing accuracy and reducing dimensional tolerances of parts significantly increases the cost of construction, however, it is necessary for providing the specified output torque and smooth running. So, additional cost-effectiveness studies of the design and manufacture of a magnetic coupling are required. In addition, it is necessary to study the work of magnetic couplings with high slip, because using asynchronous motors in mechanical engineering more is profitable.
Using copper discs for torque transmission is quite expensive. This fact requires the study of magnet couplings with discs made of other magnetic materials. Finding a trade-off between design efficiency and cost remains a major challenge for manufacturing.
7 Conclusions
The method and mathematical model for calculating the parameters of a magnetic coupling combined with a stop have been developed. The resulting mathematical model is convenient for engineering use and requires no additional expensive software. The developed model takes into account the decrease of properties of magnets and copper during heating, as well as the operation of the coupling when fixing the torque. The experiment showed the influence of manufacturing accuracy and eddy losses at a high slip speed on the torque.
In accordance with the developed method, the coupling was designed and tested experimentally. A correlation between the mathematical model of the coupling and the experiment was obtained. A correction factor of 0.75 was introduced into the mathematical model to account for torque reduction due to inaccuracies in coupling fabrication and eddy losses at high slip speed. The analytical calculation of convective heat transfer combined with numerical calculation using the FEM makes it possible to effectively solve the problem of the cooling design. At the same time, it is important to take into account the cost of its manufacturing.
7.1 Future works
Since the function of eddy losses is non-linear, and the magnetic coupling operates on a high slip, an additional study of the dependence of the correction factor on the slip value is required. It is also required to perform electromagnetic FEM simulation of the coupling.
References
Beller S, Yavuz H (2021) Crane automation and mechanical dam** methods. Alex Eng J 60(3):3275–3293. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2021.01.048
Yang X, Liu Y, Wang L (2019) Nonlinear modeling of transmission performance for permanent magnet eddy current coupler. Math Probl Eng. https://doi.org/10.1155/2019/2098725
Belguerras L, Mezani S, Lubin T (2021) Analytical modeling of an axial field magnetic coupler with cylindrical magnets. IEEE Trans Magn 57(2):1–5. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMAG.2020.3005949
Flankl M, Tüysüz A, Gong C, Stolz T, Kolar JW (2018) Analysis and modeling of eddy-current couplings for auxiliary power generation on a freight train wagon. IEEE Power Energy Technol Syst J 5(4):139–147. https://doi.org/10.1109/JPETS.2018.2871629
De la Barriere O, Hlioui S, Ben Ahmed H, Gabsi M, LoBue M (2012) 3-D formal resolution of Maxwell equations for the computation of the no-load flux in an axial flux permanent-magnet synchronous machine. IEEE Trans Magn 48(1):128–136. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMAG.2011.2167347
Mouton Z, Kamper MJ (2014) Modeling and optimal design of an eddy current coupling for slip-synchronous permanent magnet wind generators. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 61(7):3367–3376. https://doi.org/10.1109/TIE.2013.2282602
Smith A (1999) Magnetic drive couplings. In: IET conference proceedings. pp 232–236. https://doi.org/10.1049/cp:19991025
Stander JN, Kamper MJ, Venter G (2015) Analytic modelling and optimization of slip synchronous permanent magnet wind turbine generator topologies. Wind Energy 18(7):1221–1238. https://doi.org/10.1002/we.1756
Hang X, Wang JP (2020) Permanent magnet design assisted by antiferromagnet-ferromagnet interface coupling: a Monte Carlo study. J Magn Magn Mater 500:166360. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmmm.2019.166360
Mohammadi S, Mirsalim M, Vaez-Zadeh S (2014) Nonlinear modeling of eddy-current couplers. IEEE Trans Energy Convers 29(1):224–231. https://doi.org/10.1109/TEC.2013.2288948
Lubin T, Rezzoug A (2015) 3-D analytical model for axial-flux eddy-current couplings and brakes under steady-state conditions. IEEE Trans Magn 51(10):1–12. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMAG.2015.2455955
Davies EJ (1963) An experimental and theoretical study of eddy-current couplings and brakes. IEEE Trans Power Appar Syst 82(67):401–419. https://doi.org/10.1109/TPAS.1963.291434
Rüberg T, Kielhorn L, Zechner J (2021) Electromagnetic devices with moving parts-simulation with FEM/BEM coupling. Mathematics. https://doi.org/10.3390/math9151804
Cheng X, Liu W, Tan Z, Zhou Z, Yu B, Wang W, Zhang Y, Liu S (2020) Thermal analysis strategy for axial permanent magnet coupling combining fem with lumped-parameter thermal network. Energies 13(19):5019. https://doi.org/10.3390/en13195019
Lubin T, Rezzoug A (2017) Improved 3-D analytical model for axial-flux eddy-current couplings with curvature effects. IEEE Trans Magn 53(9):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMAG.2017.2714628
Fontchastagner J, Lubin T, Mezani S, Takorabet N (2018) Design optimization of an axial-field eddy-current magnetic coupling based on magneto-thermal analytical model. Open Phys 16(1):21–26. https://doi.org/10.1515/phys-2018-0004
Lubin T, Mezani S, Rezzoug A (2013) Experimental and theoretical analyses of axial magnetic coupling under steady-state and transient operations. IEEE Trans Ind Electron 61(8):4356–4365. https://doi.org/10.1109/TIE.2013.2266087
Wang J, Lin H, Fang S, Huang Y (2014) A general analytical model of permanent magnet eddy current couplings. IEEE Trans Magn 50(1):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMAG.2013.2279073
Selimefendigil F, Öztop HF (2021) Thermal management and modeling of forced convection and entropy generation in a vented cavity by simultaneous use of a curved porous layer and magnetic field. Entropy 23(2):152. https://doi.org/10.3390/e23020152
Rehman Z, Seong K (2018) Three-D numerical thermal analysis of electric motor with cooling jacket. Energies. https://doi.org/10.3390/en11010092
Jia M, Hu J, **ao F, Yang Y, Deng C (2021) Modeling and analysis of electromagnetic field and temperature field of permanent-magnet synchronous motor for automobiles. Electronics. https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics10172173
Bejan A, Kraus AD (2003) Heat transfer handbook, vol 1. Wiley, Hoboken
Acknowledgements
We thank Innopolis University for generously funding this endeavour.
Funding
The authors have not disclosed any funding.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
Conceptualization, all authors; methodology, all authors; validation, all authors; investigation, SV; resources, SV; writing—original draft preparation, SV and BMR; writing—review and editing, all authors; visualization, all authors; supervision, SP and BMR; project administration, BMR. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Suvorov, V.A., Bahrami, M.R., Sorokin, P.A. et al. Mathematical model and experimental study of a magnet coupling with a stop. SN Appl. Sci. 4, 286 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-022-05175-w
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-022-05175-w