Abstract
Tooth size variation within fossil assemblages can be associated with intra- or interspecific variation, functional, developmental, and geographical factors, and/or sexual dimorphism. Understanding these sources of variation is necessary to develop diagnoses for fossil mammals, where teeth are usually the most frequent remains. Tremacyllus (Ameghino, 1891) (Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata) is a genus of small-sized herbivorous mammals abundant in late Miocene to Pliocene outcrops of southern South America. Its simplified, euhypsodont dentition and size variability have hampered systematics studies and led, for instance, to an overestimation of the number of species. I analyzed tooth size variations within assemblages of Tremacyllus in a quantitative framework to test three hypotheses: (1) magnitudes of size variation are different among tooth loci and assemblages; (2) tooth size follows a geographical pattern within the analyzed sample (Bergmann’s rule), but is also associated with taxonomy; and (3) there is a correlation between size variation and sexual dimorphism reflected in distinguishable subgroups. Results indicate that patterns of variation might be associated with eruption time and/or functional position. Northwestern forms are larger than southwestern-Pampean ones, not conforming to Bergmann’s rule but revealing a strong influence of latitude. Size differences between assemblages agree with dental features that distinguish T. incipiens and T. impressus, allowing expanded species diagnoses. Two size subgroups might reflect sexual dimorphism in the absence of biostratigraphic or morphological differences between them. This interpretation indicates that northwestern specimens referred to T. diminutus should be referred to T. incipiens.
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig1_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig2_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig3_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig4_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig5_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig6_HTML.png)
![](http://media.springernature.com/m312/springer-static/image/art%3A10.1007%2Fs10914-021-09575-4/MediaObjects/10914_2021_9575_Fig7_HTML.png)
Similar content being viewed by others
Availability of Data and Material
Raw data generated during the current study are publicly available.
References
Ameijeiras-Alonso J, Crujeiras RM, Rodríguez-Casal A (2019) Mode testing, critical bandwidth and excess mass. Test 28(3):900–919
Ameijeiras-Alonso J, Crujeiras RM, Rodriguez-Casal A (2021) multimode: An R Package for Mode Assessment. J of Statistical Softw 97(1):1–32
Ameghino F (1885) Nuevos restos de mamíferos fósiles oligocenos recogidos por el Profesor Pedro Scalabrini y pertenecientes al Museo Provincial de la ciudad de Paraná. Bol Acad Nac Cien Córdoba 8:5–207
Ameghino F (1891) Mamíferos y aves fósiles argentinos. Especies nuevas, adiciones y correcciones. Rev Arg Hist Nat 1:240–259
Ameghino F (1908) Las formaciones sedimentarias de la región litoral de Mar del Plata y Chapalmalán. An Mus Nac Buenos Aires 3:343–428
Andersson M (1994) Sexual Selection. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.
Armella MA (2019) Sistemática, bioestratigrafía y paleobiogeografía de los notoungulados del Neógeno del Noroeste Argentino. Dissertation, Universidad Nacional de Tucumán
Armella MA, Domínguez L, Georgieff SM, Esteban GI, Sabater S (2020) First radioisotopic age and sedimentary analysis of the Las Cañas Formation in Termas de Río Hondo, Santiago del Estero (Northwestern Argentina). J South Am Earth Sci 104:102868
Armella MA, Ercoli MD, Bonini RA, García-López DA (in press) Detecting morphological gaps in teeth outlines of a Pachyrukhinae (Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata) lineage: systematic and palaeobiogeographical significance of the records from Northwestern Argentina. Comptes Rendus – Palevol
Armella MA, García-López DA, Esteban GI (2015) Nuevo registro y revisión del género Tremacyllus (Pachyrukhinae, Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata) del Mioceno tardío de la Provincia de Catamarca. Ameghiniana 52(4):R6
Armella MA, García-López DA, Esteban GI (2019) Paleobiogeografía del Orden Notoungulata en el Neógeno del Noroeste Argentino: análisis integral de los registros de la región. Act Res V Simp Mio-Pleist Centro y Norte Arg:165–168
Armella MA, Madozzo Jaén C, Nasif NL, García-López DA, Esteban GI, Ortiz PE, González R, Babot J, Georgieff S (2016) Vertebrados de la Formación Andalhuala en la localidad de Encalilla, Tucumán, Argentina. Ameghiniana 53(1):R4
Barreda V, Anzótegui M, Prieto A, Aceñolaza PM, Bianchi M, Borromei AM, Brea M, Caccavari M, Cuadrado GA, Garralla S, Grill S, Guerstein GR, Lutz A, Mancini MV, Mautino LR, Ottone EG, Quattrocchio M, Romero EJ, Zamaloa MC, Zucol A (2007) Diversificación y cambios de las angiospermas durante el Neógeno en Argentina. Ameghiniana 11:173–191
Benaglia T, Chauveau D, Hunter D, Young D (2009) mixtools: An R package for analyzing finite mixture models. J of Statistical Softw, 32(6):1–29
Bergmann KGLC (1847) Über die Verhältnisse der wärmeokönomie der Thiere zu ihrer Grösse. Göttinger Studien 3:595–708
Biernacki C, Celeux G, Govaert G (2000) Assessing a mixture model for clustering with the integrated completed likelihood. IEEE Trans Pattern Anal Mach Intell 22(7):719–725
Billet G, Bardin, J (2021) Segmental series and size: clade-wide investigation of molar proportions reveals a major evolutionary allometry in the dentition of placental mammals. Syst Biol. https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syab007
Blackburn TM, Gaston KJ, Loder N (1999) Geographic gradients in body size: a clarification of Bergmann’s rule. Div and Dist 5:165–174
Bonhomme V, Picq S, Gaucherel C, Claude J (2014) Momocs: outline analysis using R. J of Statistical Softw 56:1–24
Bonini R (2014) Bioestratigrafía y diversidad de los mamíferos del Neógeno de San Fernando y Puerta de Corral Quemado (Catamarca, Argentina). Dissertation, Universidad Nacional de La Plata
Burmeister CV (1888) Relación de un viaje a la Gobernación de Chubut. An Mus Nac Buenos Aires 3:175–222
Cerdeño E, Bond M (1998) Taxonomic Revision and Phylogeny of Paedotherium and Tremacyllus (Pachyrukhinae, Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata) from the late Miocene to the Pleistocene of Argentina. J Vertebr Paleontol 18:799–811
Cerdeño E, Reguero M (2015) The Hegetotheriidae (Mammalia, Notoungulata) assemblage from the late Oligocene of Mendoza, central-western Argentina. J Vertebr Paleontol 35:e907173
Cerdeño E, Montalvo CI, Sostillo R (2017) Deciduous dentition and eruption pattern in Paedotherium (Pachyrukhinae, Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata) from Late Miocene of La Pampa Province, Argentina. Hist Biol 29:359–375
Cheng MY, Hall P (1998) Calibrating the excess mass and dip tests of modality. J R Statist Soc: Series B (Statistical Methodology) 60(3):579–589
Conover WJ, Iman RL (1981) Rank transformations as a bridge between parametric and nonparametric statistics. Am Statistician 35(3):124–129
Copes LE, Schwartz GT (2010) The scale of it all: postcanine tooth size, the taxon-level effect, and the universality of Gould’s scaling law. Paleobiol 36(2):188–203
Creighton GK (1980) Static allometry of mammalian teeth and the correlation of tooth size and body size in contemporary mammals. J Zool 191(4):435–443
Domingo L, Tomassini RL, Montalvo CI, Sanz-Pérez D, Alberdi MT (2020) The Great American Biotic interchange revisited: a new perspective from the stable isotope record of Argentine pampas fossil mammals. Sci Rep 10:1–10
Elissamburu A, Dondas A, De Santis L (2011) Morfometría de las paleocuevas de la “Fm”. Chapadmalal y su asignación a Actenomys (Rodentia), Paedotherium (Notoungulata) y otros mamíferos fósiles hospedantes. Mastozool Neotrop 18(2):227–238
Ercoli MD, Candela AM, Rasia LL, Ramírez MA (2017) Dental shape variation of Neogene Pachyrukhinae (Mammalia, Notoungulata, Hegetotheriidae): systematics and evolutionary implications for the late Miocene Paedotherium species. J Syst Palaeontol 16(13):1073–1095
Fairbairn DJ, Blanckenhorn WU, Székely T (2007) Sex, Size and Gender Roles: Evolutionary Studies of Sexual Size Dimorphism. Oxford University Press. Oxford
Fox J, Weisberg S (2019) An R Companion to Applied Regression, Third Edition. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage. https://socialsciences.mcmaster.ca/jfox/Books/Companion/
Garrido AC, Turazzini GF, Bond M, Aguirrezabala G, Forasiepi AM (2014) Estratigrafía, vertebrados fósiles y evolución tectosedimentaria de los depósitos neógenos del Bloque de San Rafael (Mioceno-Plioceno), Mendoza, Argentina. Act Geol Lilloana 26:133–164
Georgieff SM, Muruaga CM, Ibañez LM, Spagnuolo C, Bonini R, Esteban G, Nasif N, Del Pero MA (2017) Estilos de deformación, cronoestratigrafía y evolución paleoambiental de las unidades neógenas de las Sierras Pampeanas Noroccidentales de Catamarca y Tucumán, Argentina. In: Muruaga CM, Grosse P (eds) Ciencias de la Tierra y Recursos Naturales del NOA, Relatorio del XX Congreso Geológico Argentino. San Miguel de Tucumán, pp 254–268
Gingerich PD (1974) Size variability of the teeth in living mammals and the diagnosis of closely related sympatric fossil species. J Paleont 48(5):895–903
Godfrey LR, Lyon SK, Sutherland MR (1993) Sexual dimorphism in large-bodied primates: the case of the subfossil lemurs. Am J Phys Anth 90(3):315–334
Gomes Rodrigues H, Lefebvre R, Fernández-Monescillo M, Mamani Quispe B, Billet G (2017) Ontogenetic variations and structural adjustments in mammals evolving prolonged to continuous dental growth. R Soc Open Sci 4(7):170494
Gould SJ (1975) On the scaling of tooth size in mammals. Am Zoologist 15(2):353–362
Greenwood PJ, Wheeler P (1985) The evolution of sexual size dimorphism in bird and mammals: a “hot blooded” hypothesis. In: Greenwood PJ, Harvey PH, Stalkin M (eds) Evolution. Essays in Honour of John Maynard Smith. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 287–299
Hall P, York M (2001) On the calibration of Silverman’s test for multimodality. Stat Sinica 11:515–536
Hartigan JA, Hartigan PM (1985) The dip test of unimodality. Ann Stat 13:70–84
Hervé M (2021) RVAideMemoire: Testing and Plotting Procedures for Biostatistics. R package version 0.9–79. https://CRAN.Rproject.org/package=RVAideMemoire
Hijmans RJ (2020) raster: Geographic Data Analysis and Modeling. R package version 3.4-5. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=raster
Isaac JL (2005) Potential causes and life-history consequences of sexual size dimorphism in mammals. Mamm Rev 35(1):101–115
Janis CM (1990) Correlation of cranial and dental variables with dietary preferences in mammals: a comparison of macropodoids and ungulates. Mem Queensland Mus 28(1):349–366
Kaiser TM, Fickel J, Streich, WJ, Hummel J, Clauss M (2010) Enamel ridge alignment in upper molars of ruminants in relation to their natural diet. J Zool 281(1):12–25.
Kaiser TM, Fortelius M (2003) Differential mesowear in occluding upper and lower molars: opening mesowear analysis for lower molars and premolars in hypsodont horses. J Morph 258(1):67–83
Kuhl FP, Giardina CR (1982) Elliptic Fourier features of a closed contour. Comput Graph Imag Proc18(3):236–258
Lindenfors P, Gittleman JL, Jones KE (2007) Sexual size dimorphism in mammals. In: Fairbairn DJ, Blanckenhorn WU, Szekely T (eds) Sex, Size, and Gender Roles: Evolutionary Studies of Sexual Size Dimorphism, Oxford University Press, pp 16–26
Loison A, Gaillard JM, Pélabon C, Yoccoz NG (1999) What factors shape sexual size dimorphism in ungulates? Evolut Ecol Res 1(5):611–633
Loomis EB (1914) The Deseado Formation of Patagonia. Runford Press, Concord
Makowski D, Ben-Shachar MS, Lüdecke D (2019) bayestestR: Describing effects and their uncertainty, existence and significance within the Bayesian framework. J Open Sour Softw 4(40):1541
McKenna MC, Bell S (1997) Classification of Mammals Above the Species Level. Columbia University Press, New York
McNab BK (1971) On the ecological significance of Bergmann’s rule. Ecology 52(5):845–854
Meiri S (2011) Bergmann’s Rule–what’s in a name? Glob Ecol Biogeogr 20(1):203–207
Meiri S, Dayan T (2003) On the validity of Bergmann’s rule. J Biogeogr 30:331–351
Meiri S, Yom-Tov Y, Geffen E (2007) What determines conformity to Bergmann’s rule? Glob Ecol Biogeogr 16(6):788–794
Müller DW, Sawitzki G (1991) Excess mass estimates and tests for multimodality. J Am Statistic Assoc 86(415):738–746
Nakazawa M (2019) fmsb: Functions for Medical Statistics Book with some Demographic Data. R package version 0.7.0. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=fmsb
Oxnard CE (1987) Fossils, Teeth and Sex. University of Washington Press, Seattle
Pearson K (1896) Mathematical contributions to the theory of evolution. III. Regression, heredity and panmixia. Phil Trans R Soc A 187:253–318
Plavcan JM (1994) Comparison of four simple methods for estimating sexual dimorphism in fossils. Am J Phys Anth 94(4):465–476
Prado JL, Chiesa J, Tognelli G, Cerdeño E, Strasser E (1998) Los mamíferos de la Formación Río Quinto (Plioceno), provincia de San Luis. Aspectos paleoambientales y bioestratigráficos. Est Geol 54:153–160
Quin DG, Smith AP, Norton TW (1996) Eco-geographic variation in size and sexual dimorphism in sugar gliders and squirrel gliders (Marsupialia: Petauridae). Austr J Zool 44(1):19–45
R Core Team (2017, 2020) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.r-project.org/
Reguero MA, Candela AM, Alonso RN (2007) Biochronology and biostratigraphy of the “Uquian” mammals (Pliocene-Early Pleistocene, NW of Argentina) and their significance in the Great American Biotic Interchange. J South Am Earth Sci 23:1–16
Reguero MA, Candela, AM, Cassini G 2010. Hypsodonty and body size in rodent-like notoungulates. In: Madden R, Carlini AA, Vucetich MG, Kay R (eds) The Paleontology of Gran Barranca: Evolution and Environmental Change through the Middle Cenozoic of Patagonia. Cambridge University Press, New York, pp 362–371
Reuter DM, Hopkins SS, Davis EB (2021) Carnivoran intraspecific tooth-size variation shows heterogeneity along the tooth row and among species. J Mamm 102(1):236–249
Riggs ES, Patterson B (1939) Stratigraphy of the Late-Miocene and Pliocene deposits of the Province of Catamarca (Argentina) with notes on the faunae. Physis 14:143–162
Rovereto, C. 1914. Los estratos araucanos y sus fósiles. An Mus Nac Hist Nat 25:1–247.
Schwarz G (1978) Estimating the dimension of a model. Ann Stat 6(2):461–464
Shelomi M, Zeuss D (2017) Bergmann’s and Allen’s rules in native European and Mediterranean Phasmatodea. Front Ecol Evol 5:25
Scrucca L, Fop M, Murphy TB, Raftery AE (2016) mclust 5: clustering, classification and density estimation using Gaussian finite mixture models. The R J 8(1):289
Scherrer B (1984) Biostatistique. Gaëtan Morin Editeur, Montréal
Simpson GG (1945) The principles of classification and a classification of mammals. Bull. Am. Mus Nat Hist 85:1–350
Simpson GG (1948) The beginning of the age of mammals in South America. Part I. Bull Am Mus Nat Hist 91:1–232
Silverman BW (1981) Using kernel density estimates to investigate multimodality. J R Statist Soc: Series B (Methodological) 43(1):97–99
Sostillo R, Cerdeño E, Montalvo CI (2018) Taxonomic implications of a large sample of Tremacyllus (Hegetotheriidae: Pachyrukhinae) from the late Miocene Cerro Azul Formation of la Pampa, Argentina. Ameghiniana 55:407–422
Szuma E (2000) Variation and correlation patterns in the dentition of the red fox from Poland. Annales Zoologici Fennici 37:113–127
Tauber AA (2005) Mamíferos fósiles y edad de la Formación Salicas (Mioceno tardío) de la sierra de Velasco, La Rioja, Argentina. Ameghiniana 42:443–460
Tauber AA, Krapovickas JM, Marengo H, Haro A (2014) Paleontología del Cenozoico. In: Martino RD, Guereschi AB (eds) Relatorio de la Geología y Recursos Naturales de la Provincia de Córdoba, 19º Congreso Geológico Argentino. Córdoba, Argentina, pp 591–621
Tomassini RL (2012) Estudio tafonómico y bioestratigráfico de los vertebrados de la Formación Monte Hermoso (Plioceno) en su localidad tipo, provincia de Buenos Aires. Dissertation, Universidad Nacional del Sur
Tomassini RL, Montalvo CI, Deschamps CM, Manera T (2013) Biostratigraphy and biochronology of the Monte Hermoso Formation (early Pliocene) at its type locality, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina. J South Am Earth Sci 48:31–42
van Hinsbergen DJ, De Groot LV, van Schaik SJ, Spakman W, Bijl PK, Sluijs A, Langereis CG, Brinkhuis H (2015) A paleolatitude calculator for paleoclimate studies. PloS one 10(6): e0126946
van Valkenburgh B, Sacco T (2002) Sexual dimorphism, social behavior, and intrasexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivorans. J Vertebr Paleontol 22:164–169
Vera B (2016) Phylogenetic revision of the South American notopithecines (Mammalia: Notoungulata). J Syst Palaeontol 14(6):461–480
Vera B, Ercoli MD (2018) Systematic and morphogeometric analyses of Pachyrukhinae (Mammalia, Hegetotheriidae) from the Huayquerías, Mendoza (Argentina): biostratigraphic and evolutionary implications. J Vertebr Paleontol 38(3):e1473410
Vitzthum VJ (1990) Odontometric variation within and between taxonomic levels of cercopithecidae: Implications for interpetations of fossil samples. Hum Evol 5(4):359
Zetti J (1972) Los mamíferos fósiles de edad huayqueriense (Plioceno medio) de la región pampeana. Dissertation, Universidad de La Plata
Acknowledgments
I thank D. Croft, the associate editor, J. Tejada, and two anonymous reviewers for their useful comments and suggestions that improve this study. Also, I thank D.A. García-López for his helpful comments on the first version of this manuscript. The following curators and collection managers kindly allowed access to specimens in their care: P. Ortiz (Colección Paleontología Vertebrados Lillo, San Miguel de Tucumán, Tucumán, Argentina); S. Sabater (Museo Municipal ‘Rincón de Atacama’, Termas de Río Hondo, Santiago del Estero, Argentina); C. Montalvo (Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Universidad Nacional de La Pampa, Santa Rosa, La Pampa, Argentina); A. Kramarz (Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales ‘Bernardino Rivadavia’, Buenos Aires, Argentina); and M. Reguero (Museo de La Plata, La Plata, Buenos Aires, Argentina). I acknowledge G. Esteban, N. Nasif, and R. Bonini for their comments on the paleontological context of the findings. I also thank to M. Ercoli for sharing specimen photographs (FMNH) and M.C. Gallo for dispelling doubts on statistical approaches.
Funding
Asociación Paleontológica Argentina, Argentina (APA-Bunge & Born Grants 2017; awarded to M.A. Armella); and Secretaría de Ciencia, Arte e Innovación Tecnológica, Universidad Nacional de Tucumán, Argentina (PIUNT 2018 G-626).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics Approval
Not applicable.
Consent to Participate
Not applicable.
Conflicts of Interest/Competing Interests
Not applicable.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Armella, M.A. Tooth Size Variation in Assemblages of Tremacyllus (Hegetotheriidae, Notoungulata): Insights into Geographical Gradients, Systematics, and Sexual Dimorphism. J Mammal Evol 29, 113–128 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10914-021-09575-4
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10914-021-09575-4