Introduction

The use of fossil fuels and nitrogen (N) fertilizers for agricultural production has significantly increased the transfer rate of reactive N from the atmosphere to terrestrial ecosystems (Galloway et al. 2008), having a cascade of effects (Galloway et al. 2003; Sutton et al. 2011) on, for example, biodiversity (Bobbink et al. 2010), eutrophication (Bouwman et al. 2002) or air quality and human health (Galloway et al. 2008). In N-limited forests, enhanced atmospheric N deposition usually increases plant growth and soil carbon (C) stocks through the slowdown of litter and soil organic matter decomposition (Pregitzer et al. 2008; de Vries et al. 2009; Janssens et al. 2010). In forests where N saturation thresholds (Aber et al. 1998) are surpassed—i.e. when N availability exceeds ecosystem N demand, further increases in N input rates may lead to soil acidification, biodiversity loss and leaching of base cations (Bobbink et al. 2010). The tightly coupling between the C and N biogeochemical cycles may lead to important variations in the aboveground and belowground C cycle in response to increased N deposition (Gruber and Galloway 2008), affecting bulk soil respiration (RS) in both its autotrophic and heterotrophic components (Janssens et al. 2010).

Several meta-analyses have addressed the effects of increased N deposition on RS among forest biomes, with overall results showing a decline (Janssens et al. 2010; Zhou et al. 2014; Zhong et al. 2016). Nitrogen addition may reduce RS rates through three main mechanisms: (1) declined rhizosphere activity with reduced plant belowground C allocation in favour of aboveground tissue production (Pregitzer et al. 2008; de Vries et al. 2009), (2) changes in the abundance, composition and/or activity of soil saprophytic communities (Frey et al. 2004; Treseder 2008), which in turn influence the microbial carbon use efficiency (CUE; Liu et al. 2018), and (3) soil organic matter stabilization via soil acidification and chemical protection (Janssens et al. 2010; Averill and Waring 2018). However, these response patterns are not universal, since other competing mechanisms—e.g. alleviation of microbial N limitation or stimulation of photosynthesis—may positively impact RS (Högberg et al. 2006). Further, N turnover processes are highly sensitive to variations in soil moisture and temperature regimes (Dirnböck et al. 2017), which may also have contributed to the observed discrepancies in the effects of N addition on RS. There is an interplay between N deposition effects and climate constrains affecting plant and microbial activities (Zhou et al. 2014; Zhong et al. 2016). As a result, the specific role of biotic and abiotic processes in inducing changes in RS remains elusive (Waldrop and Zak 2006; Riggs and Hobbie 2016). In addition, in Mediterranean regions dry N deposition dominates and N accumulates on soil and plant surfaces during drought periods; when rainfall comes, N availability suddenly increases in the soil and these N flushes are decoupled from plant physiological demand (Fenn et al. 2003; Ochoa-Hueso et al. 2011). Overall, there is limited evidence of N deposition impacts on soil properties under the specificities of the Mediterranean ecosystems, impeding a robust prediction of the RS response.

Tree species composition is an additional player in the effect of rising N deposition on belowground C cycling, since trees strongly shape the soil system through the biochemistry of detritus inputs, microbial community, pH, nutrient availabilities and mineralization processes (Bobbink et al. 2010; Zhong et al. 2016; Averill and Waring 2018). In the broadleaved-coniferous ecotone forests of Pyrenean oak (Quercus pyrenaica Willd.) and Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) in Central Spain, tree species composition leads to marked differences in soil pH, nutrient stoichiometry and C decomposability (Díaz-Pinés et al. 2011b; Fernández-Alonso et al. 2018a; Table 1). These differences indicate that pine stands generate a more oligotrophic environment in which N is strongly limiting. Furthermore, forest successional changes are currently taking place as a result of global change favouring an upwards expansion of the Pyrenean oak distribution at the expense of Scots pine (Galiano et al. 2010; Ruiz-Labourdette et al. 2012; Moreno-Fernández et al. 2016). However, there is a gap in our current understanding of the interactive effects between some aspects of global change—e.g. increased N deposition and forest composition shifts—on belowground C dynamics in Mediterranean ecosystems. In this sense, different physiological tree responses are likely to yield different outcomes upon environmental stressors in soils (Sher et al. 2004; Ochoa-Hueso et al. 2011). The development of this knowledge will also be relevant to understand the functioning of forest soils in other geographical areas under Mediterranean climate, namely the Mediterranean basin, California (USA) and Baja California (Mexico), where oak and pine forests are dominant elements.

Table 1 Main soil and vegetation characteristics at the experimental sites
Full size table

We conducted a multi-level manipulation experiment simulating an increase in atmospheric N deposition at the altitudinal contact between Scots pine and Pyrenean oak forests in Central Spain. This Mediterranean region is affected by N pollutant mainly from metropolitan areas and livestock production (Ochoa-Hueso et al. 2011; Escudero et al. 2016). Throughout 3 years, we applied 0 (control), 10 (medium) and 40 kg N ha−1 a−1 (high) as wet deposition over the 10–15 kg N ha−1 a−1 of background atmospheric N deposition (García-Gómez et al. 2014). We combined RS measurements and annual soil samplings performed 24 h after the N fertilization events (i.e. short-term response) with monthly RS measurements.

Our specific objectives were to (1) quantify the impact of enhanced N deposition rates on RS; (2) elucidate whether tree-species composition control the observed differences; (3) evaluate the response of soil chemical and biological attributes to the N flushing events originated by the rains in Mediterranean regions; and (4) explore the causal relationships among soil attributes and determine how they may be affected in the short-term by N fertilization events. We hypothesized that (i) increased N deposition will negatively affect RS rates, with larger effects for high N inputs (Janssens et al. 2010; Zhou et al. 2014; Zhong et al. 2016). We anticipated (ii) a high temporal variability in the response of RS to N additions driven by the marked seasonality of the Mediterranean climate. Further, we expected that (iii) RS under pine will show higher sensitivity to N inputs than under oak, based on the oligotrophic soil environment under pine compared to the copiotrophic soil environment under oak. Finally, we hypothesized that (iv) increases in soil N availability will reduce microbial biomass and soil pH in the short-term, as it has been generally observed in forests (Zhou et al. 2014; Riggs and Hobbie 2016).

Material and methods

Study site

The study was carried out in Valsaín Mountains, in the northern slopes of the Guadarrama Range (Central Spain, 40° 51′ N, 4° 3′ W) at 1350 m above sea level, where the altitudinal belts of pure Pyrenean oak and pure Scots pine forests overlap. The current composition and structure of the forests are the result of an intense and lasting human management; tree species distributions are shifting in the last decades because of global change drivers, namely climate and land management (Moreno-Fernández et al. 2016). These mountains are affected by air pollution in form of NOx originated from highways and urbanization (e.g. Segovia, a settlement of 55,000 inhabitants at 10 km distance) and NH3 from animal husbandry (e.g. pig farms) (Ochoa-Hueso et al. 2011; Escudero et al. 2016). The background atmospheric N deposition ranges from 10 to 15 kg N ha−1 a−1 (García-Gómez et al. 2014). This area has a continental Mediterranean mountain climate with a mean annual precipitation of 648 mm and a mean annual temperature of 10.4 °C (2014–2017). There is a strong seasonality, with the precipitation being concentrated mostly from late autumn to mid spring. The summer is warm and has a marked drought that lasts roughly from July to September. The winter is cold and a thin snow cover may be present up to several weeks, although it is highly variable between years. Soils are Humic Cambisols (IUSS Working Group WRB 2015) formed on a siliceous bedrock with sandy loam texture.

Two representative areas separated by a distance of 1400 m in the altitudinal ecotone were used for the experiment: one Pyrenean oak coppice and one even-aged Scots pine forest. The oak forest has a density of 932 stems ha−1 of around 60-year old, resulting from an earlier use as a coppice which stopped during the early 1960s (** (Finney and DiStefano 2006). Before assessing the models, we checked for multi-collinearity patterns in our dataset calculating the variance inflation factor of each predictor variable and using a threshold level of four. Furthermore, we explored if there were differences in the influence of N fertilization on RS between forests through the explicit comparisons performed with a multi-group analysis (Shipley 2004). We applied the Bonferroni correction to adjust the overall significance level to the number of cases tested in these multi-group comparisons.

Statistical analyses were carried out in the statistical platform R version 3.4.0. (R Core Team 2019) except for the fit and evaluation of SEMs and the multi-group analyses, which were performed with the Amos 22.0.0 software (SPSS, IBM Corporation, Meadville, PA, USA). Significance level was established in all tests at p < 0.05, unless otherwise stated.

Results

Soil properties as affected by vegetation type

There were no statistical differences in soil microclimate between forests (Kruskal–Wallis, df = 1; soil water content, χ2 = 0.930; soil temperature, χ2 = 0.922). Mean soil temperature was 12.2 ± 0.6 °C (ranging from 1.4 °C in winter to 23.8 °C in summer) and mean soil moisture was 8.2 ± 1.4% vol. (ranging from < 1% in summer to 21.3% in late winter). During winter and late-autumn, oak stands tended to have higher soil moisture levels (Fig. 1), although this trend was not statistically significant.

Fig. 1
figure 1

Soil microclimate parameters and soil respiration (RS) rates over the study period (June 2014–May 2017). Average values of a soil temperature and b soil water content in the experimental plots (n = 12) from Scots pine and Pyrenean oak forests. Mean RS measured in c the Scots pine forest and d the Pyrenean oak forest from control, medium- and high-fertilization plots (n = 4). Standard errors are omitted to improve the clarity of the figure. Arrows indicate days of application of nitrogen fertilization. Grey and white panels indicate the seasons: SP spring, SU summer, AU autumn and WI winter

Full size image

The soil microbial C and N was lower in pine stands than in oak ones (12.1 ± 5.6 and 21.5 ± 4.8 mg C g−1 SOC; 33.3 ± 14.8 and 48.1 ± 14.9 mg N g−1 TN; respectively in the top 10 cm; layer-wise results in Table S1). The soil microbial C:N ratio was lower under oak than under pine (6.2 ± 1.4 and 7.9 ± 1.6, respectively in the top 10 cm). The SOC stock in the uppermost 10 cm was significantly higher in the pine than in the oak forest (42.7 ± 13.4 and 35.1 ± 5.4 Mg C ha−1, respectively; layer-wise results in Table S2), while the contrary was observed for the soil N stocks (2.0 ± 0.6 and 2.6 ± 0.4 Mg N ha−1 in pine and oak stands, respectively). Soil C:N ratio in the pine forest was nearly twofold the one in the oak forest (21.8 ± 2.4 and 13.2 ± 0.9, respectively).

Ammonium was the dominant inorganic-N form in the soils, regardless of tree species (Table S2). In control plots the NO3−-N:NH4+-N ratio was on average 0.14 ± 0.09 and 0.23 ± 0.19 in pine and oak forests, respectively. Soil NH4+ and NO3− concentrations in the uppermost 5 cm of the soil were higher in oak than in pine forests (Fig. 2c; Table S2). Soil pH was slightly more acidic in the pine than in the oak forest (Fig. 2d). The K+ concentrations were higher in oak than in pine stands (Fig. 2e). Extractable PO43− was low (3.8 ± 1.4 mg P kg−1 dw) and rather similar between forests in the top layer (Table S2). The qCO2 was significantly higher in Scots pine than in Pyrenean oak forests (Fig. 3; Table S3).

Fig. 2
figure 2

Selected soil properties separated by tree species and N-fertilization treatment at 0–5 cm depth (mean ± 1 standard error). Cmic microbial biomass carbon, EOC extractable organic carbon, NO3− nitrate concentration, K potassium concentration. Different capital letters denote significant differences between tree species within the same N-fertilization treatment (control, medium- and high-fertilization), while different small letters indicate significant differences between N-fertilization treatments within the same tree species (linear mixed-effects models, n = 12)

Full size image
Fig. 3
figure 3

Microbial metabolic quotient (qCO2) according to tree species and N-fertilization treatments (mean ± 1 standard error). Different capital letters denote significant differences between tree species, while different small letters indicate significant differences between N-fertilization treatments (generalized linear mixed model, n = 12)

Full size image

Short-term effects of N additions on soil properties

In the short term, soil microbial biomass C decreased after N addition in both tree species and in the two soil depths analysed (Figs. 2a, S2a), while microbial biomass N remained unaffected (Table S1). The soil microbial C:N ratio was not influenced by N fertilization in any of the studied soil layers, despite a non-significant reduction in the uppermost 5 cm of the soil under pine of 1.3–1.5 units (Table S1). In the first 5 cm of the soil under pine, the EOC decreased with N addition whereas it remained stable in the soil under oak (Fig. 2b). Nitrate concentrations showed a significant increase in fertilized plots, with a larger response in the first 5 cm of the soil profile (Figs. 2c, S2c). Soil pH values showed a small but significant reduction with the high-N fertilization in both forests (Fig. 2d). In both forests, K+ concentrations were higher under medium-fertilization compared to high-fertilization, whereas control plots showed intermediate values (Fig. 2e). In both forests, the medium-fertilization treatment showed increased qCO2 values compared to the control treatment (Fig. 3; Table S3).

Soil respiration

Soil respiration followed the same temporal pattern in both oak and pine forests (Fig. 1; Table 2): RS peaked in March–July and in October, corresponding to the periods with high values of both soil temperature and soil moisture (Fig. 1). For the period from May to August (the period with the warmest soil temperature) RS was higher in the oak than in the pine forest. The medium-fertilization significantly increased RS in the Scots pine stand from February to May and in September, whereas the high-fertilization only showed significant increases in February. In the oak forest, medium-fertilization significantly increased RS only in April with high-fertilization showing intermediate values between control and medium-fertilization. The fertilization effect on cumulative RS throughout the study period (2014–2017) was not statistically significant in any of the forests (Fig. 4; Table S4). In the oak stand, RS rates increased 24 h after fertilizer spreading (Fig. 5), but the same trend was found in the control in which only water was applied (p < 0.1, Fig. 5b). In the pine forest, no significant short-term response of RS to the application of fertilizers was found (Fig. 5).

Table 2 Monthly averaged soil respiration (Mg CO2-C ha−1 month−1)
Full size table
Fig. 4
figure 4

Cumulative soil respiration rates (mean ± 1 standard error) from June 2014 to May 2017 (36 months) for each tree species and treatment (p > 0.05, n = 4)

Full size image
Fig. 5
figure 5

Box-plot of the soil respiration rates before and 24 h after nitrogen fertilizer spreading in a Scots pine and b Pyrenean oak. The horizontal line represents the median value (n = 48); the box represents the interquartile range (IQR, 25th–75th percentile range); the lower (higher) whisker shows the smallest (greatest) observation greater than (less than) or equal to the 25th percentile minus (plus) 1.5 times the IQR. Circles represent observations falling out the median ± 1.5 × IQR range. For each tree species and N-fertilization treatment, the χ2 and p-values of the Kruskal–Wallis test of “moment of measurement” are presented

Full size image

Direct and indirect effects of soil properties on soil respiration

The datasets collected in each forest provided a good fit to the initial hypothesized model as indicated by the non-significant χ2 values and the goodness of fit indices (RMSE < 0.05, NFI and GFI > 0.9; Browne and Cudeck 1993, Fig. 6a, b). The SEMs were able to explain the 51% and 58% of the variation in RS in the Scots pine and the Pyrenean oak forests, respectively. The predictor variables soil moisture and soil temperature that were similar in both forests during the measurement campaigns, explained the greatest amount of variability in RS and had stronger standardized effects in the Pyrenean oak forest than in the Scots pine forest (Fig. 6c; Table S6). The SEMs revealed a strong effect of N fertilization on soil NO3− concentrations, but not on soil NH4+ concentrations (Fig. 6a, b; Table S5). Soil NH4+ concentrations negatively influenced RS in both forest types; whereas soil NO3− concentrations stimulated RS in the pine forest, only (Fig. 6c). The direct effect of N additions on soil pH was only significant in the oak forest, although in both forests N fertilization indirectly reduced soil pH through the modulation of NO3− (Fig. 6a, b; Table S5). Soil pH in turn exerted a total negative effect on RS (Fig. 6c). Fertilization acidified the soil, which resulted in higher RS rates in both forests. Microbial biomass C did not influence RS in any of the tree species (Fig. 6c), albeit its strong reduction after N additions (Fig. 6a, b). Further, the paths from N fertilization to EOC and from EOC to RS differed in direction, statistical significance and magnitude between forests (Table S6). The EOC increased with soil acidification in both tree species (Fig. 6a, b), with negative effects for RS in pine and positive in oak (Fig. 6c). In soils under pine, the reduction in microbial biomass C with N fertilization caused a modest increase in EOC (Fig. 6a; Table S5). The EOC experienced a strong decrease with N additions in the pine stand (Fig. 6a; Table S5). The interconnections between the inorganic N forms and pools of C (Stock C and EOC) were different between forests (Table S6). The total effect of fertilization on RS was positive and significant only in the case of the pine stand (Fig. 6c).

Fig. 6
figure 6

Overall structural equation models for the Scots pine forest (a) and the Pyrenean oak forest (b). Values adjacent to paths indicate standardized regression weights. Only significant relationships (p < 0.05) are depicted (see the hypothesized model in Fig. S1). Arrow widths are proportional to estimated regression weights. Squared multiple correlations (R2) of dependent variables are also shown. Goodness of fit statistics for each model are: NFI Bentler and Bonnett’s normed fit index, GFI goodness of fit index, RMSEA root mean square error approximation. See Fig. S1 for the nomenclature used in the rectangles. c Standardized total effects (direct plus indirect effects) of tested variables on RS for each forest stand. Asterisks indicate levels of significance: ***p-value < 0.001, **p-value < 0.01, *p-value < 0.05, n.s. non-significant

Full size image

Discussion

Soil respiration response to enhanced N deposition rates

We hypothesised reductions of RS rates for both tree species in response to N enrichment since it is the generally observed trend in temperate forests in manipulative experiments (Janssens et al. 2010; Zhou et al. 2014; Zhong et al. 2016). This has to be rejected since we observed largely no response (or even transient increases) in the RS rates in the fertilized treatments (Table 1; Fig. 4). We suggest that the marked seasonality of the Mediterranean climate, which strongly constrains soil biological activity, is mostly responsible for the observed stability (Fig. 1). Even if the availability of soil N increases, water scarcity and/or low temperatures may still limit plant nutrient uptake (Sardans et al. 2011) or soil microbial transformations, and thereby RS (Almagro et al. 2009; Fernández-Alonso et al. 2018b). Following this argument, the seasonality of precipitations influences not only the RS rates per se, but also its response to N addition, which is suppressed during the dry period (Zhang et al. 2014; Lo Cascio et al. 2017). Likewise, the soil activity was limited in winter due to the low temperatures and the apparently higher soil moisture values observed in the oak stand after leaves senescence did not trigger a differential response upon rewetting (Figs. 1, 5). Thus, we propose a hierarchy in environmental limitations, in which the climate constraints of the Mediterranean regions play a predominant role in limiting the RS response to the addition of N and, when appropriate microclimatic conditions occur, the soil N status becomes more relevant.

In forest ecosystems, the response of RS is likely related to the a priori soil N status (Zhu et al. 2016). While the general trend is a decrease in the RS following fertilization, Janssens et al. (2010) speculated that the few observed positive RS responses were provoked by the alleviation of microbial N limitation. In our case, RS in pine stands showed a positive reaction upon medium-fertilization from February to May and then in September, while the response in oak stands was only detectable in April. In line with the current study, partner works in the area have shown large differences in the soils under each tree species (Table 1). Soils under pine have markedly higher C:N ratios (Díaz-Pinés et al. 2011b), lower inorganic N contents (Table S2), and also higher biogeochemical recalcitrance of soil organic matter compared to oak soils in the ecotone (Díaz-Pinés et al. 2011b). Further, the tree species composition shapes the structure of the microbial functional groups in soils, being the saprophytic fungi more abundant in the pine stand and the gram-negative bacteria in the oak stand (Díaz-Pinés et al. 2014; Fernández-Alonso et al. 2018a), and resulting in higher soil microbial C:N ratio under pine than under oak (Table S2). Overall, previous and current results suggest a N-poor environment under pine, with predominantly oligotrophic microorganisms, whereas more copiotrophic microbes dominate under oak (Fernández-Alonso et al. 2018a). Thus, the stronger N limitation in pine stands results in a higher response upon fertilization than in the oak ones, in line with studies reporting how, after N addition, the native N availability—derived from soil stoichiometry—inhibits RS in N richer sites and enhances RS in N poorer ecosystems (Pregitzer et al. 2008; Zhu et al. 2016; Lo Cascio et al. 2017).

We investigated bulk RS rates and therefore we cannot discriminate whether N addition affected the root or the microbial respiration component, or both. Positive effects of N additions on RS might have been produced through a plant-mediated response by which alleviation of N limitation enhances the photosynthetic rates, inducing a positive loop in the forest C cycle by enhancing rhizosphere respiration (Lu et al. 2011). Further, changes in quantity and quality of the litterfall can subsequently affect its decomposition dynamics (Knorr et al. 2005). However, given the small size of our plots, we suggest that the effect of our fertilization on plant growth was rather limited and we consider more plausible that the observed effects are primarily originated in changes in the heterotrophic component of RS following direct incorporation of the N into the soil.

Short-term soil response to enhanced N availability

In Mediterranean forests, dry N deposition dominates and tends to accumulate on soil and plant surfaces (Fenn et al. 2003; Ochoa-Hueso et al. 2011), so that, seasonal rains may induce enhanced inorganic N availability affecting soil attributes and RS. In our experiment, we only detected a pulse in RS (at the oak forest) that was associated to the spray of water and not to higher N availability, since it also occurred in the control plots (Fig. 5). However, we observed a full range of short-term changes in other soil chemical and biological properties for both investigated tree species 24 h after fertilization (Fig. 2).

In line with our hypotheses, there was a positive relationship between the NO3− concentrations in soils and the N-fertilization rates, subsequently leading to soil acidification and decreased microbial biomass C (Knorr et al. 2005; Zhou et al. 2014; Riggs and Hobbie 2016). The higher soil NO3− concentration with high N fertilization doses is associated with base cation leaching (Bobbink et al. 2010; Cusack et al. 2016; Li et al. 2018), which may explain the lower concentrations of K+ and lower soil pH values we found in high-fertilized plots when compared to the control or the medium-fertilization treatment. Further, N addition is linked to decreases in microbial activity, which usually elevates EOC levels (Waldrop and Zak 2006; Zak et al. 2008; Liu and Greaver 2010). On the other hand, enhanced microbial nitrification and its subsequent acidification effect have been related to a decline of EOC (Evans et al. 2008). In our study, it seems that the effect of acidification dominated over the impact of reduced soil microbial activity on EOC, especially in soils under pine that were already slightly more acidic than under oak prior to the manipulation experiment (4.3 vs. 5.1 soil pH in pine and oak, respectively).

The addition of N to the soil induced a 25% reduction of microbial biomass C in the top 10 cm of the soil in the pine forest and 15% reduction in the oak forest. To match these observations with the lack of responses of fertilization on RS (Fig. 4), a strong decrease in CUE had to occur, as shown by the increase in qCO2 (i.e. a lower use of C for growth favouring RS, Sinsabaugh et al. 2013; Fig. 3). In the short-term and especially in N-limited ecosystems, the alleviation of N constraints on microbial activity with inorganic N supply may increase the demand for labile C due to increases in cellulose-degrading enzymes and decreases in lignin-degrading enzymes (Waldrop and Zak 2006; Janssens et al. 2010; Liu and Greaver 2010). In both forests, the displayed qCO2 trend among N treatments (i.e. medium-fertilization ≥ high-fertilization ≥ control) suggests the existence of a threshold in the cumulative amounts of N that shift soil properties and functioning (Lo Cascio et al. 2017). In these acidic soils, where the exchangeable base pool is presumably smaller than the total exchangeable acidity, the base cation losses with heavy N loads within several decades could lead to soil acidification (Reuss and Johnson 1986; Janssens et al. 2010) and negative effects on microbial and plant activity (DeForest et al. 2004; Sinsabaugh et al. 2008).

Long-term perspective

The observed moderate response of RS upon increased N deposition is probably due not only to the Mediterranean environmental conditions, but also to the relatively lower background atmospheric N deposition rates (10–15 kg N ha−1 a−1) compared to other forest ecosystems in Central Europe (up to 38 kg N ha−1 a−1, Pilegaard et al. 2006). While average N atmospheric deposition rates have declined since the 1990s by 30–50% in Central and Western Europe, south-western Europe shows increases in throughfall N deposition rates larger than 30% (Schmitz et al. 2019) as well as increases in NOx emissions (Fagerli and Aas 2008). Our study investigated the effects over 3 years only; and our observations fit in the first stages of N ecosystem enrichment following increases in N deposition (Aber et al. 1998). Despite the modest response of RS following fertilization, the observed acidification, the loss of base cations and the decreased soil microbial biomass in the short-term suggest that stronger effects in the belowground C and N cycles may occur with further increases in N enrichment.

Conclusions

The RS showed a high resilience to 3 years of soil N enrichment in this Mediterranean ecotone forest. Our results suggest the characteristic seasonal variability of soil moisture and temperature as the main factors constraining and modulating the RS response to N additions. We further propose a hierarchy on drivers modulating the RS response by which, when appropriate microclimatic conditions occur, soil N status—as shown by soil stoichiometry along with inorganic N contents—becomes more relevant. Hence, the more N-limited soil beneath the Scots pine showed higher RS sensitivity to increased N availability, with the medium-fertilization rates increasing RS compared to the control treatment, than the Pyrenean oak forest. Moreover, the short-term negative changes on soil properties observed in these acidic soils—e.g. soil acidification, the loss of base cations and reduced microbial biomass, emphasizes the need to investigate whether these effects persist in the long run, and what would be their consequences for the belowground C and N cycles.