Introduction

Autophagy is an evolutionarily conserved mechanism with a potential role in organelle and protein turnover that may also be involved in regulating metabolism and controlling cell quality [1, 2]. The process of autophagy is dependent on lysosomes and the main goal of autophagy is to provide nutrients and energy, which can be achieved by the degradation of cytoplasmic substituents. In addition, autophagy is crucial in the process of eliminating toxic proteins and defective organelles during the aging process [3]. There is increasing evidence that autophagy can influence cellular specialization, differentiation, protein trafficking, and unconventional secretion [4,5,6]. Autophagy is classified into three categories: Macroautophagy, microautophagy, and chaperone-mediated autophagy [7]. In this review, we focus on macroautophagy and refer to it simply as autophagy. The basic level of autophagy is required under normal conditions, but its induction can be mediated by metabolic changes [8, 56]. The incidence rate of HCC is two to four times higher in men compared to women [56]. HCC is considered the sixth most common cancer worldwide and up to 500,000 new cases are diagnosed annually, which are responsible for a high mortality rate, making it the third leading cause of death among tumors [60, 61]. The incidence rate of HCC is estimated to be 3.6–10.5 per 100,000, which may increase to 16 per 100,000 worldwide [62, 63]. The survival rate of HCC patients is low, with 5% of them surviving more than 5 years after diagnosis. This is related to the late diagnosis of HCC patients and only 15% of patients are eligible for liver transplantation and surgery. 50% of them undergo non-surgical therapies and 35% or more receive the best treatment during diagnosis [63]. Risk factors for HCC vary and may include alcohol consumption, hepatitis virus infection, cirrhosis, and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease [64].

The progression of HCC depends on the interaction of some mechanisms and pathways at the molecular level. Phosphorylation of Fis1 occurs through Met to mediate mitochondrial fission and promote HCC migration [65]. CD44 can increase the expression of YAP to promote HCC progression [66]. It seems that obesity is a driving force for HCC progression. PI3Kγ ablation decreases HCC proliferation and reduces insulinemia, steatosis, and inflammatory cytokine concentration [67]. ZRANB1, as a deubiquitinate, is involved in the increasing progression and malignancy of HCC and, to this end, increases LOXL2 expression to promote tumor metastasis [120]. CCAT2 mediates unfavorable prognosis in HCC [121] and may increase the expression of NDRG1 and MDM2 in promoting tumor progression [122, 123]. Overexpression of CCAT2 is observed in HCC samples and leads to advanced stage and venous invasion. CCAT2 decreases the expression of miR-4496 in the cytoplasm to promote ATG expression, trigger autophagy, and enhance metastasis of HCC cells [124]. One of the best-known regulators of autophagy is Beclin-1, which was mentioned in the introduction. BMP4 stimulates c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) signaling to increase the expression of Beclin-1 in autophagy induction, leading to a marked increase in HCC cell metastasis and invasion [125].

Glycochenodeoxycholate (GCDC) is one of the components of bile acid and can cause liver damage due to its hydrophobic acidic nature [80, 126,127,128,129,130]. Hydrophobic bile acid can lead to apoptosis and necrosis in hepatocytes [131]. In HCC, GCDC has been associated with an increase in progression and metastasis of HCC cells. GCDC promotes AMPK expression to inhibit mTOR signaling, leading to induction of autophagy and increased tumor cell invasion [132]. It appears that a lack of autophagy, which may be mediated by caveolin-1, leads to induction of angiogenesis and acceleration of metastasis in HCC [133].

Autophagy and EMT

EMT is the closest mechanism associated with tumor cell invasion and metastasis, as well as their resistance to therapy, and is characterized by morphological and physiological changes such as loss of cell polarity, disruption of intracellular junctions, increase in growth and invasion, increase in N-cadherin and vimentin levels, and decrease in E-cadherin [134,135,136,137]. Fluid shear stress (FSS) increases autophagosome formation and promotes the expression of Beclin-1, ATG7, and LC3II to mediate EMT and enhance HCC cell metastasis [138].

Autophagy and anoikis

Anoikis is a type of detachment from the extracellular matrix (ECM) [139] and the development of resistance to anoikis is critical for cancer cells to enhance their invasion and metastasis [140]. During anoikis resistance, there may be activation of autophagy, which is responsible for adaptation to stressful conditions such as oxidative stress, starvation, hypoxia, and metabolic reprogramming [141]. There is growing evidence of a link between autophagy and anoikis resistance in HCC. Acidic extracellular pH inhibits mTOR signaling via upregulation of AMP-protein kinase (AMPK) expression to induce autophagy. Moreover, miR-3663-3p is downregulated at acidic extracellular pH to induce autophagy, which promotes anoikis resistance in HCC [142]. Therefore, autophagy stimulates anoikis resistance in increasing progression and metastasis of HCC cells. miR-30a reduces the levels of Beclin-1 and ATG5 to suppress autophagy and anoikis resistance and limit metastasis of HCC cells [143]. AEG-1 stimulates phosphorylation of ULK1 to stimulate autophagy in mediating anoikis resistance and enhancing HCC cell invasion [144]. Based on these studies, targeting autophagy and related molecular signaling pathways is of importance in treating HCC and reducing cancer cell metastasis (Fig. 4) [145].

Fig. 4
figure 4

Targeting autophagy to regulate metastasis in HCC. Anoikis resistance and EMT as the two most important factors in regulating HCC cell invasion are influenced by autophagy mechanism. When autophagy has an oncogenic function, its induction by Beclin-1 and AMPK/mTOR signaling pathway may lead to EMT induction, which promotes tumor metastasis

Regulation of proliferation by autophagy has shown that interfering with this mechanism may provide new insights into how tumor survival is affected. Most importantly, autophagy has been found to be related to metastasis as another feature of HCC. Autophagy may act as a trigger/inhibitor of metastasis in HCC. Overexpression of ATG2A and ATG14 leads to autophagy and a subsequent increase in metastasis of HCC cells, whereas inhibition of the Beclin-1/autophagy axis by SOCS5 promotes metastasis. Since metastasis is closely related to the malignancy of tumor cells and may also mediate chemoresistance, induction of autophagy in HCC cells, when acting as a tumor suppressor, may contribute significantly to the impairment of carcinogenesis.

Targeting autophagy for regulating drug resistance

Basic evolution of drug resistance in HCC

The process of chemoresistance in HCC has been challenging in recent years, and prevention of mitochondrial respiration and stimulation of oxidative stress have been responsible for overcoming chemoresistance [146]. Overexpression of ICMT prevents apoptosis and induces doxorubicin resistance in HCC [147]. Overexpression of Nrf2 induces chemoresistance in HCC and metformin suppresses Nrf2-mediated glycolysis, thereby increasing the drug sensitivity of cancer cells [148]. Downregulation of USP7 reduces HCC cell growth and metastasis and is responsible for drug sensitivity [149]. Glyochenodeoxycholic acid stimulates STAT3 signaling to promote stem cell formation of HCC cells and mediates drug resistance [150]. Therefore, molecular pathways contribute to HCC cell progression and mediate drug resistance, so the role of autophagy mechanism in this aspect is under investigation.

Related molecular pathways

Upregulation of CD24 is observed in HCC cells and those resistant to sorafenib chemotherapy. CD24 increases the expression of PP2A and suppresses the mTOR/Akt axis to induce autophagy, which triggers sorafenib resistance in HCC [151]. The redox status of tumor cells is different from that of normal cells [152], and overexpression of antioxidant factors can enhance the progression of HCC cells [153]. Ferroptosis is a type of programmed oxidative cell death characterized by stimulation of the Fenton reaction, which promotes the formation of ROS and increases the accumulation of lipid peroxidation products [154]. Sorafenib can cause depletion of GSH, triggering ferroptosis in HCC [155, 156]. Overexpression of CISD2 in HCC is responsible for sorafenib resistance in tumor cells. Silencing of CISD2 stimulates apoptosis and uncontrolled autophagy in HCC and increases sorafenib-mediated ferroptosis in tumor cells [157]. Inhibition of pro-survival autophagy is important for increasing sorafenib sensitivity of HCC cells. Downregulation of miR-541 in HCC leads to sorafenib resistance and suppresses proliferation, metastasis, and autophagy in vitro and in vivo. miR-541 decreases ATG2A and RAB1B levels to inhibit autophagy and increase sorafenib sensitivity of HCC cells [158]. Although the function of miR-541 is critical for enhancing drug sensitivity in HCC, upregulation of miR-25 leads to sorafenib resistance. miR-25 decreases FBXW7 expression to trigger autophagy in mediating sorafenib resistance in HCC [159].

The expression of Rage is found in various types of cells [160] and has been found to be associated with the progression of inflammatory diseases such as cancer [160,161,162]. Recently, the role of Rage in regulating the progression of HCC cells has been investigated. CircRNA-101368 increases Rage levels and thus promotes HCC progression [163]. The upregulation of Rage in HCC promotes the growth rate of HCC cells and stimulates sorafenib resistance. Loss of Rage expression leads to stimulation of AMPK signaling to reduce mTOR expression in autophagy induction and promote sorafenib response in HCC [164]. Yes-associated protein (YAP) is one of the new targets in HCC therapy and KAT6A increases the expression of YAP, which promotes HCC progression and mediates sorafenib resistance [165]. Cinacalcet inhibits the YAP /TAZ axis to prevent HCC progression [166]. Moreover, overexpression of YAP leads to EMT induction, which enhances HCC metastasis [167]. An experiment has shown that overexpression of YAP can lead to drug resistance in HCC. Inhibition of YAP increases drug sensitivity in HCC via mediating autophagy-induced cell death. Knockdown of YAP leads to increased RAC1-mediated ROS generation to suppress mTOR signaling, resulting in autophagy induction and chemosensitivity in HCC [168].

Autophagy and apoptosis in chemoresistance

The major pathway by which chemotherapeutic agents exert cytotoxicity on tumor cells is the induction of apoptosis, which can be stimulated by both mitochondria and endoplasmic reticulum stress (ER). ER Stress leads to activation of the UPR, which can mediate apoptosis [169, 170]. Moreover, ER stress can induce both apoptosis and autophagy, and compounds targeting ER stress are of interest for the treatment of disease and cancer [171]. In HCC cells exposed to sorafenib, overexpression of IRE1 is critical for the induction of autophagy via the ER stress signaling pathway. Moreover, activation of autophagy reduces ER stress-induced apoptosis in HCC. Therefore, inhibition of autophagy and its targeting may improve the potential of chemotherapeutic agents in apoptosis induction in HCC [172,173,174]. Table 2 summarizes the role of autophagy in drug resistance in HCC.

Table 2 Targeting autophagy for drug sensitivity in HCC

The process of chemoresistance is highly complicated and it is impossible to target all the molecular pathways involved in this condition, but it is possible to adopt some of the most important mechanisms in this case. Because of the interaction of autophagy with other cell death mechanisms, its induction may mediate ferroptosis in enhancing drug sensitivity, while inhibition of autophagy by miR-541 is critical in preventing chemoresistance, again demonstrating the dual function of autophagy in this case. One of the drawbacks of the current studies is that they did not focus on other chemotherapeutic agents such as doxorubicin, paclitaxel, and others, but focused on sorafenib. Future studies should therefore pay particular attention to the role of autophagy in the resistance of HCC to the above agents.

Targeting autophagy for regulating radioresistance

Modulation of radioresistance in HCC is of importance because it is a conventional therapy for HCC. If the potential of therapy is reduced due to resistance, a functional analysis of genes should be performed to reveal the role of factors involved in progression and resistance. Radiotherapy stimulates CD8+ T cell function to impair HCC progression, and sorafenib is considered an inhibitor of radioresistance [175]. HCC cells overexpressing γ GCSh prevent apoptosis, which is beneficial for inducing radioresistance [176]. This section focuses on the role of autophagy in regulating radioresistance in HCC. NEAT1 is a regulator of autophagy in cancer and its downregulation can stimulate autophagy and ferroptosis [177]. The upregulation of NEAT1 in HCC has been associated with an important property known as radioresistance. This effect is mediated by overexpression of gamma-aminobutyric acid receptor-associated protein (GABARAP) and induction of autophagy [178]. The effect of autophagy on radioresistance in HCC is uncertain. Irradiation of HCC cells leads to autophagy induction, and oxaliplatin promotes autophagy activation by increasing the cytotoxicity of radiotherapy in the treatment of HCC [179]. However, most studies have focused on the role of autophagy as a pro-survival mechanism in triggering radioresistance. ASPP is an apoptosis regulatory protein and has three members, including ASPP1, ASPP2, and iASPP. ASPP2 is downregulated in HCC due to its methylation [180, 181]. Moreover, ASPP2 prevents autophagy to increase cell response to RAS [182]. Downregulation of ASPP2 may lead to an increase in HCC cell survival. Low expression of ASPP2 leads to overexpression of Beclin-1 and induction of autophagy [183]. Previous experiments have investigated the role of ASPP2 in the regulation of autophagy and its association with drug resistance, and future studies may be warranted to investigate its role in radioresistance. RAD001 is an inhibitor of mTOR signaling that stimulates autophagy as a pro-death mechanism to enhance autophagy and the efficacy of radiotherapy in combating HCC [184]. Saikosaponin-d promotes LC3 levels and increases autophagosome formation to stimulate autophagy and increase the radiosensitivity of HCC cells [185]. The biological effects of irradiation are mediated by the formation of ROS [186]. Irradiation can increase the formation of ROS and mediates oxidative stress [187]. Thus, when the levels of ROS decrease, the sensitivity of HCC cells to radiotherapy decreases. URI1 induces AMPK phosphorylation to increase forkhead box O3 (FOXO3) levels to trigger autophagy via increased autophagosome formation and prevent ROS formation by radiotherapy in HCC [188]. According to these studies, targeting autophagy and regulating related molecular signaling pathways are important for modulating the response of HCC cells to radiotherapy (Fig. 5) [189,190,191,192,193].

Fig. 5
figure 5

Autophagy, drug resistance, and radioresistance in HCC. Based on the function of autophagy in regulating proliferation and metastasis of HCC cells, this metabolic pathway may be involved in regulating radio- and chemoresistance of HCC cells. The resistance of HCC cells to sorafenib and oxaliplatin is tightly regulated by the autophagy mechanism. Moreover, activation of autophagy by NEAT1 may lead to radioresistance. More importantly, autophagy can reduce the levels of ROS in triggering radioresistance

Although the focus of many studies has been on drug resistance, there have also been attempts to demonstrate the role of autophagy in mediating radioresistance in HCC. Most studies show that induction of cytotoxic autophagy is important in mediating radiosensitivity. One of the most important aspects is the use of chemotherapeutic agents such as oxaliplatin together with radiotherapy to stimulate pro-death autophagy and reduce HCC progression.

Anticancer agents modulating autophagy in hepatocellular carcinoma

Synthetic drugs

The use of anticancer agents, other than chemotherapeutic agents, is an increasing trend in the treatment of HCC as resistance to conventional therapies develops [194,195,196]. Shikonin is an inhibitor of HCC progression and suppresses the PI3K/Akt/mTOR axis to stimulate both apoptosis and autophagy to reduce cancer cell malignancy [197]. However, when an anti-cancer agent stimulates autophagy, it does not mean that autophagy promotes tumor progression. Thus, in HCC, myricetin stimulates both apoptosis and autophagy by affecting endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress. Although activation of ER stress by myricetin stimulates apoptosis to reduce HCC progression, activation of autophagy is a supportive mechanism, and its inhibition may enhance the anticancer effect of myricetin anticancer therapy [198].

Imatinib is a tyrosine kinase inhibitor and impairs HCC cell metastasis by increasing NM23 expression (199). To improve the anti-cancer activity of imatinib against HCC, attempts have been made to combine it with other antitumor agents such as sulfasalazine and GNF-5 [200, 201]. Moreover, incorporation of imatinib into lactoferrin-modified PEGylated liquid crystalline nanostructures induces apoptosis in HCC via the mitochondrial pathway [202]. Imatinib prevents phosphorylation of protein kinase B (Akt) and promotes expression of p62 and suppresses progression of HCC in vitro and in vivo. Imatinib impairs HCC progression via regulating the above signaling pathways to inhibit autophagy [203].

Natural compounds

Another antitumor agent that is popular in HCC treatment is dioscin. Dioscin suppresses TGF-β1-induced EMT in HCC to reduce cancer cell metastasis [204]. In addition, dioscin increases Bax and caspase-3 levels and decreases Bcl-2 levels in apoptosis induction in HCC [205]. Dioscin stimulates apoptosis, autophagy, and DNA damage in HCC cells and reduces growth and metastasis. Dioscin increases the levels of Beclin-1 and LC-3 and decreases the levels of p-Akt and p-mTOR in inducing autophagy and promoting progression of HCC cells [206]. Another strategy is the simultaneous use of two anticancer drugs. For example, in one experiment, costunolide (CL) and dehydrocostuslactone (DCL) were used as two bioactive components of an extract of sesquiterpene lactones to treat HCC. CL and DCL promote the accumulation of LC3 and p62 to suppress autophagy and prevent HCC progression [207]. In the previous sections, it has been shown that inhibition of autophagy may be beneficial in improving apoptosis induction in HCC. However, when autophagy has a death-promoting function, its inhibition decreases apoptosis. Isoqerucetin stimulates the AMPK/mTOR/p70S6K axis to mediate apoptosis and autophagy in HCC. Inhibition of autophagy decreases apoptosis by lowering the Bax/Bcl-2 ratio and preventing capase-3 activation and PARP cleavage, confirming the anticancer effect of autophagy in HCC [208].

The most controversial part is that the function of autophagy in HCC is completely different depending on the conditions. For example, a previous experiment showed that imatinib suppresses autophagy in HCC therapy [203]. However, another experiment shows that ursodeoxycholic acid promotes LC3B expression to stimulate autophagy and thus prevent HCC progression [209]. Moreover, both studies have shown that autophagy is regulated in vitro and in vivo and has an effect on the progression of HCC.

Resveratrol is an effective anti-cancer agent against HCC and suppresses Akt signaling by increasing phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) expression, thereby reducing the malignancy of HCC [210]. Resveratrol promotes anti-tumor immunity in HCC by reducing the number of CD8+ CD122+ Treg cells [211]. Moreover, resveratrol reduces Gli-1 expression in HCC suppression [212]. Resveratrol is able to upregulate the expression of p53 and suppress the PI3K/Akt signaling pathway to induce autophagy to prevent the progression of HCC [213]. Moreover, flavopereirine induces autophagy to prevent the progression of HCC [214]. Based on these studies, most of the anti-tumor agents targeting autophagy (induction or inhibition) in the treatment of HCC are natural products and have shown promising results [215,216,217]. However, natural products have poor bioavailability [218, 219], and their future application may be facilitated by using nanostructures for their delivery in the treatment of HCC and modulation of autophagy (Fig. 6; Table 3).

Fig. 6
figure 6

Regulation of autophagy by anti-cancer agents in the treatment of HCC. Molecular pathways related to autophagy, such as PI3K/Akt/mTOR, AMPK, and LC3II, are regulated by anticancer drugs. Of note, induction of autophagy by antitumor agents not only has a pro-death function, but sometimes also a pro-survival function, so in this case, inhibition of autophagy increases the potential of antitumor agents to induce apoptosis

Table 3 Use of anticancer compounds for targeting autophagy in HCC treatment

This section has shown that modulation of autophagy by synthetic and natural agents offers a great opportunity for improved efficacy in the treatment of HCC. Sometimes, autophagy induced by anti-tumor agents has a pro-survival function, and in this case, inhibition of autophagy is suggested to enhance its efficacy in cancer therapy. One of the gaps in the current field is that studies have ignored the role of small molecules in regulating autophagy in HCC. Since the molecular signaling pathways related to autophagy such as ATGs, Beclin-1, and AMPK have been recognized and their structure has also been understood, it is highly recommended to develop new small molecules to affect autophagy in HCC therapy in the near future.

Conclusion and remarks

The autophagy mechanism is a molecular event in normal and cancer cells that has a completely different function depending on the context. In normal cells, the goal of autophagy is to break down aged organelles and decompose toxins. Therefore, a baseline level of autophagy or its induction may be beneficial for maintaining homeostasis under physiological conditions. However, as cancer cells progress, they may induce or inhibit autophagy depending on their condition to improve their survival rate. Since HCC is the most malignant and lethal liver cancer, the influence of autophagy on tumor cell progression needs to be emphasized. Autophagy has two distinct functions in HCC that impact survival and death. In the context of the pro-survival function, induction of autophagy can significantly enhance progression and viability of HCC cells, whereas pro-death autophagy impairs tumor progression. ER stress can mediate both apoptosis and autophagy in HCC cells, and inhibition of pro-survival autophagy has been shown to be beneficial in increasing ER stress-mediated apoptosis in tumor cells. AMPK, Beclin-1, and the Akt/mTOR pathway are the major regulators of autophagy that have been studied in HCC. Autophagy can increase HCC cell viability and prevent apoptosis, whereas death-promoting autophagy exerts a different function. Activation of autophagy may lead to increased invasion of HCC cells and induce EMT, whereas anti-cancer autophagy suppresses tumor cell migration. In addition, targeting autophagy is of interest to increase the sensitivity of HCC cells to drugs and radioactivity. Quercetin, resveratrol, and lycorine are among the compounds that target autophagy in the treatment of HCC. Induction of autophagy by anticancer agents does not indicate their tumor-suppressive effects, and sometimes inhibition of autophagy may improve the cytotoxicity of these agents in combating HCC. Future application of these findings in the clinic could greatly improve the prognosis, survival, and ability to treat HCC patients.

Basic research is important when it is translated into clinical practice in the treatment of patients. The current situation in the treatment of HCC patients is complicated because physicians face various problems in treating patients. Regardless of the lack of specific and highly sensitive tools for early diagnosis of HCC patients, their diagnosis in advanced and metastatic stages leads to difficulties in treatment, especially due to resistance to therapy. The clinical application of autophagy in these patients is that autophagy can be assessed prior to therapy to predict tumor cell response, and then a more effective therapeutic regimen can be applied to patients. Furthermore, since gene therapy has only recently entered the field of cancer therapy, it is possible that in the near future, factors related to autophagy can be targeted and modulated to enable more effective treatment of cancer patients.