Abstract
A life cycle assessment(LCA) was conducted over the modified Siemens method polycrystalline silicon(S-P-Si) wafer, the modified Siemens method single crystal silicon(S-S-Si) wafer, the metallurgical route polycrystalline silicon(M-P-Si) wafer and the metallurgical route single crystal silicon(M-S-Si) wafer from quartzite mining to wafer slicing in China. A large amount of data was investigated from relevant literature and factories in this study. Based on the contribution analysis and sensitivity analysis, the key points for improvement were found. The result included primary energy demand (PED), chemical oxygen demand (COD), SO2, NH3-N, NOX, CO2, and industrial water use (IWU). The above seven indexes were weighted and then added to get China’s thirteenth five-year plan for energy conservation and emission reduction total environmental impact indexes(ECER-135) of S-P-Si wafer, S-S-Si wafer, M-P-Si wafer and M-S-Si wafer were 1.47 × 10−9, 2.12 × 10−9, 3.30 × 10−10 and 1.22 × 10−9 respectively. The ECER-135 of silicon wafers purified with modified Siemens method was higher than that purified with metallurgical route by 3.1 times on average; the ECER-135 of single crystal silicon wafers production was larger than that of polysilicon wafers production by 2.3 times on average. When the four kinds of silicon wafers were used to generate the same amount of electricity for photovoltaic modules, the ECER-135 of S-P-Si wafer, S-S-Si wafer and M-S-Si wafer were 3.3, 4.5 and 2.8 times of that of M-P-Si wafer respectively. During the whole production process, the electricity consumption was of the highest sensitivity for ECER-135. PED had the highest contribution to the ECER-135 for four kinds of silicon wafers, mainly due to the use of thermal power. If hydropower were used instead of thermal power, the ECER-135 could be reduced by 46% to 62%.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Polaris power network news center (2019) China energy big data report (2019), China, Available from: http://news.bjx.com.cn/html/20190516/980721-3.shtml
Qi LQ, Zhang YJ (2017) Effects of solar photovoltaic technology on the environment in China. Environ Sci Pollut Res 24:22133–22142
Ray P (2019) Renewable energy and sustainability. Clean Techn Environ Policy 21:1517–1533
Gustav R, Anne H, Thomas F, Christian P, Felipe T, Reinhard H (2008) Potentials and prospects for renewable energies at global scale. Energy Policy 36:4048–4056
Zhu JQ, Wang K, Wu HW (2015) Experimental investigation on the energy and exergy performance of a coiled tube solar receive. Appl Energy 156:519–527
Zhao RR, Shi G, Chen HY, Ren AF, Finlow D (2011) Present status and prospects of photovoltaic market in China. Energy Policy 39:2204–2207
Grau T, Huo M, Neuhoff K (2012) Survey of photovoltaic industry and policy in Germany and China. Energy Policy 51:20–37
Zhang S, Philip A, Zhao XL, He YX (2013) Interactions between renewable energy policy and renewable energy industrial policy: a critical analysis of china's policy approach to renewable energies. Energy Policy 62:342–353
Zhang SF, Philip A, Ji MY (2014) The erratic path of the low-carbon transition in China: evolution of solar PV policy. Energy Policy 67:903–912
Zhu L, Xu Y, Pan Y J (2019) Enabled comparative advantage strategy in China's solar PV development Energy Policy 133:
Alexander HS, Daniel SC, Jacopo B, Charles F, Thomas M, Jean-Christophe N, Costas NP, Amin G, Corey JN, Stefano P, Folkers R, Alexander M (2011) Concentrated solar power on demand. Sol Energy 85:1519–1529
Irene R, Emilio M, Rafael E, Gustavo N, Juan DLC (2019) Analysis of the performance of various PV module Technologies in Peru. Energies 12:186
Alaaeddin MH, Sapuan SM, Zuhri MYM, Zainudin ES, Oqla FMAL (2019) Photovoltaic applications: status and manufacturing prospects. Renew Sust Energ Rev 102:318–332
Yue DJ, You FQ, Seth BD (2014) Domestic and overseas manufacturing scenarios of silicon-based photovoltaics: life cycle energy and environmental comparative analysis. Sol Energy 105:669–678
Chen W, Hong JG, Yuan XL, Liu JR (2016) Environmental impact assessment of monocrystalline silicon solar photovoltaic cell production: a case study in China. J Clean Prod 112:1025–1032
Crago CL, Koegler E (2018) Drivers of growth in commercial-scale solar PV capacity. Energy Policy 120:481–491
NEA (2015) 2014 photovoltaic power generation statistics. China, Available from: http://www.nea.gov.cn/2015-03/09/c_134049519.htm
NEA (2016) Relevant statistics of photovoltaic power generation in 2015. China, Available from: http://www.nea.gov.cn/2016-02/05/c_135076636.htm
NEA (2017) Statistics of photovoltaic power generation in 2016. China, Available from: http://www.nea.gov.cn/2017-02/04/c_136030860.htm
NEA (2018) National energy administration press conference introduces relevant energy situation in 2017. China, Available from: http://www.nea.gov.cn/2018-01/24/c_136921015.htm
NEA (2019) Statistics of photovoltaic power generation in 2018. China. Available from: http://www.nea.gov.cn/2019-03/19/c_137907428.htm
Shuai J, Chen C, Cheng JH, Leng ZH, Wang ZH (2018) Are China's solar PV products competitive in the context of the belt and road initiative? Energy Policy 120:559–568
Jacques DA, Guan D, Geng Y, Xue B, Wang XG (2013) Inter-provincial clean development mechanism in China: a case study of the solar PV sector. Energy Policy 57:454–461
Luis H, Sara G, Víctor A (2019) A review of photovoltaic systems: design, operation and maintenance. Sol Energy 188:426–440
Kouji Y, Toru H. Okabe (2010) Solar-grade silicon production by metallothermic reduction. J Miner Met Mater Soc 62: 94–101
Zhang X (2015) Progress of polysilicon production technology by improved Siemens method. Chin Sci Technol Expo 41:326
Hou Y Q, Fang W B, Zhou Y M, Tian L, Du P, Wang C L, Yu C, L Y, **e G (2018) Research progress of heat transfer in Siemens reduction furnace . J Kunming Univ Technol (NATURAL SCIENCE EDITION) 43: 1–8
Luo DW, Zhang GL, Zhang J, Li J, Li TJ (2008) Principle and research progress of solar grade silicon prepared by metallurgical method. Foundry Technol 12:1721–1726
Shi J (2011) Technological progress and Prospect of solar grade polysilicon industry by metallurgical process. New Mater Indust 3:20–24
He YQ (2009) Production of solar grade polysilicon by metallurgical method. Fine Spec Chem 2:19–21
Marina ML, Alvarez-Gaitan JP, Nathan IC, Richard C (2018) Life cycle assessment on PERC solar modules. Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 187:154–159
Brandon K, Antonino M, Miguel FA, Wesley WI, Satterfield MB, David PE, Christophy K, Tomás N, Ben A, Lise L (2018) LCA capability roadmap—product system model description and revision. Int J Life Cycle Assess 23:1685–1692
Ye H L (2008) Life cycle assessment of industrial silicon production process. Kunming University of technology
Ban H, Zou ZY, Zhang WF (2005) Energy consumption and energy saving analysis of industrial silicon production. Light Metal 48:42–43
He Y (2013) Life cycle assessment of solar grade polysilicon. Southwest Jiaotong University
**e MH, Ruan JL, Bai L, Qiao Q, Liu XQ, Yang DR, Yang LF (2015) Life cycle environmental impact assessment of solar grade polysilicon. Environ Sci Res 2:291–296
M.J. de Wild-Scholten, R. Gløckner, J.-O. Odden, G. Halvorsen, R. Tronstad (2008) LCA COMPARISON OF THE ELKEM SOLAR METALLURGICAL ROUTE AND CONVENTIONAL GAS ROUTES TO SOLAR SILICON. European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference 23rd
Yu ZQ, Ma WH, Zheng DM, Wei KX, ** FS (2016) Life cycle assessment of solar grade polysilicon prepared by metallurgical method. J Kunming Univ sci Technol (NATURAL SCIENCE EDITION) 41:16–21
Ma L, Yu ZQ, Ma WH, Qing S, Wu JJ (2019) Assessment and study on the impact on environment by multi-crystalline silicon preparation by metallurgical route. Silicon 11:1383–1391
Yuan Y, Yuan C, Eric M (2014) A hybrid life-cycle inventory for multi-crystalline silicon PV module manufacturing in China. Environ Res Lett 9
Xu L, Zhang SF, Yang MS, Li WL, Xu J (2018) Environmental effects of China's solar photovoltaic industry during 2011–2016: a life cycle assessment approach. J Clean Prod 170:310–329
Letitia P, Davide B, Gianluca V, Ana-Maria C, Calin-Cristian C (2017) Life cycle assessment for supercritical pulverized coal power plants with post-combustion carbon capture and storage. J Clean Prod 157:10–21
Huang BJ, Zhao J, Chai JY, Xue B, Zhao F, Wang XY (2017) Environmental influence assessment of China’s multi-crystalline silicon (multi-Si) photovoltaic modules considering recycling process. Sol Energy 143:132–141
Diao ZW, Shi L (2011) Life cycle assessment of photovoltaic cell modules in China. Environ Sci Res 5:571–579
Nakajima Y (2018) Silicon crystal growth of solar cell. University, Shanghai Jiaotong
Wang W, Zhao L, Wang C (2012) The current situation of polysilicon production by changing Siemens method and metallurgical method in China. Guang zhou Chem Ind 40:21–22
Hou GF, Sun HH, Jiang ZY, Pan ZQ, Wang YB, Zhang XD, Zhao Y, Yao Q (2016) Life cycle assessment of grid-connected photovoltaic power generation from crystalline silicon solar modules in China. Appl Energy 164:882–890
Ministry of industry and information technology of the people's Republic of China (2018) Specifications and conditions for photovoltaic manufacturing industry (2018 version)
Fu YY (2013) Life cycle assessment of polysilicon photovoltaic system in China. Nan**g University
Yu Z Q (2017) Life cycle assessment of metallurgical polysilicon and its photovoltaic system. Kunming University of science and technology
Nian YB, Chen XS, He SF (2011) Research progress in the principle and production process of solar grade polysilicon prepared by metallurgy. Mineral resources. 3: 8-13
Li J (2017) Tribochemical wear of silicon materials with different crystal structures. Southwest Jiaotong University
Shimizu T, Fujikawa T, Tonsho M, Inagaki M (2001) Effect of batch feeding of limestone on NOx and SO2 emissions during petroleum coke combustion in a bubbling fluidized bed combustor. Energy Fuel 15:1220–1224
Eduardo F, Bruno C, Laura M, Alejandro S, Antonio PV, Timur V, Joaquin D (2019) Mass production test of solar cells and modules made of 100% umg silicon. 20.76% record efficiency. Energies 12:1–16
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge the support of Kunming University of Science and Technology talent introduction research start-up fund project in 2018 (provincial) (KKSY201852006) and National college students innovation and entrepreneurship training program in 2019 (201910674002).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Fan, M., Yu, Z., Ma, W. et al. Life Cycle Assessment of Crystalline Silicon Wafers for Photovoltaic Power Generation. Silicon 13, 3177–3189 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12633-020-00670-4
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12633-020-00670-4