SpringerLink
Log in

Uncertainty in life cycle impact assessment of toxic releases practical experiences - arguments for a reductionalistic approach?

Impact assessment of toxic releases in a substance flow analysis for PVC in sweden

  • Lca Case Studies
  • Published:
The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

This paper describes the experience with impact assessment of toxic releases in a Substance Flow Analysis (SFA) for PVC in Sweden. For this system, all emissions related to the PVC-chain were inventoried. They have been evaluated making use of the Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCIA) step from the CMI.-guide, including the new toxicity equivalency factors calculated with the Uniform System for Evaluation of Substances (USES). The application of this method led to the conclusion that I.CA Impact Assessment of toxic releases is still a major bottleneck: the USES-equivalency factors are not to he trusted due to outdated data, inappropriate defaults, etc. in the USES’ substance properties database. Therefore, a second USES-ser of factors was calculated that differed up to factors of 1,000 or more from the old ones. Even these factors probably suffer from unacceptable high structural, in practice not reducible uncertainties. In conclusion, we warn the LCA community not to overestimate the possibility of LCA Impact Assessment to obtain a meaningfull priority setting with regard to toxicity problems. Instead, we propose develo** indicator systems for LCIA of toxic releases that genuinely deal with all relevant types of uncertainty: data uncertainty, modelling uncertainty and particularly paradigmatic uncertainty.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Subscribe and save

Springer+ Basic
EUR 32.99 /Month
  • Get 10 units per month
  • Download Article/Chapter or Ebook
  • 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
  • Cancel anytime
Subscribe now

Buy Now

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Amsterdamska, O. andR. Hacendijk (1990): De nieuwe zekerheden van het hedendaagse wetenschapsonderzoek [The new certainties of present day’s research of science]. Kennis en methode 1990/1

  • Berg, N.V.D. et al. (1995): Beginning LCA. Unilever and CML, Leiden, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Bowden, G. (1985): The Social Construction of Validity in Estimates of US Crude Oil Reserves. Social Studies of Science, Vol.15,207–40

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Braunschweig, A., R. Forster, P. Hofstetter R. Mueller-Wenck (1996): Developments in LCA valuation. IWO Diskussions- papier Nr. 32, St. Gallen, Switzerland

    Google Scholar 

  • CML (1996): Letter concerning default data in USES to the readers of Guinée et al. (1996a). CML, Leiden, 1996

    Google Scholar 

  • Consou, F. D. Allen, I. Boustead, J. Fava, W. Franklin, A.A. Jensen, N. De Oude, R. Parrish, R. Perriman, D. Postlewaite, B. Quay, J. Seguin andB. Vicon (1993): Guidelines for Life-Cycle Assessment: A Code of Practice. SETAC, Brussels, Belgium

    Google Scholar 

  • Colborn, T., D. Dumanoski andJ.P. Mayers (1996): Our stolen future: are we threatening our fertility, intelligence and survival. Penguin Books Inc. USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Copius Peerkboom, J.W. (1996): A disputable chlorine balance. (in Dutch), Milieu 1996/5, Boom Publishers, Meppel, The Netherlands

    Google Scholar 

  • Cowan, C.E., D. Mackay, T.C.J. Fkitkl, D.V.d. Mefnt, A. Di Guardo,J.Davies N. Mackay (1995): The Multimedia Fate Model: A vital tool for prediction of the fate of chemicals.SETAC Press, Pensacola, Florida, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Cranor, C.F. (1993): Regulating toxic substances. A philosophy of science and the law. Oxford university press, New York, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • DOSE (undated, continuous updates), The Dictionary of Substances and their effects. CD-ROM, The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK

  • Douglas, M. andA. Wildavsky (1982): Risk and Culture. University of California Press, Berkeley, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • EDF (Environmental Defense Fund) (1997): Toxic Ignorance. EDF, Washington D.C., USA (also available at: www.edf.org)

  • Funtowicz, S.O. andJ.R. Ravetz (1990): Uncertainty and quality in science for policy. Theory and Decision Library, ser. A, Vol. 15, Kluwer, Dordrecht, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Finnveden, G. L-G. Lindfors, andL. Wennberg (1996): Alternativa material till PVC. IVL Rapport B 1232, IVL, Stockholm, Sweden

    Google Scholar 

  • Finnveden, G. andL-G. Lindfors (1997): Life cycle impact assessment and interpretation. In: Udo de Haes and Wrisberg (1997)

  • Finnveden, G. (1997): Letter to the editor. Int. J. LCA 2 (4) 185

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Gunther, A. andH-C. Langowski (1997): Life Cycle Assessment Study on Resilient Floor Coverings. Int. J. LCA 2(2) 73–80

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  • Gunther, A. andH-C. Langowski (1997): Life Cycle AssessmentStudy on Resilient Floor Coverings. Int. J. LCA 2(2) 73–80

    Article  CAS  Google Scholar 

  • GuinÉe, J. B., R. Heijungs, L.van Oers, D.V.D. Meent, T. Vermeire andM. Rikken (1996a): LCA Impact assessment of toxic releases.CML/RIVM, Product policy series 1996/21, Ministryfor the Environment, The Hague, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • GuinÉ, J.B.R. Heijungs, L. vanOers, D.V.D. Meent, T. Vermeire andM. Rikken (1996b): USES. Uniform System for the Evaluationof Substances. Inclusion of Fate in LCA Characterizationof Toxic Releases Applying USES 1.0. Int. J. LCA 1 (3)133–138

    Google Scholar 

  • Heijungs, R., J.B. GuinÉ, G. Huppes, R.M. Lankreijkr, H.A. Udo de Haes, A. Wegener Sleeswijk, A.A.M. Ansems, P.G. Egcels, R. van Duin andH.P. de Goedf. (1992): Environmental Lifecycle Assessment of Products, Guide and backgrounds. CML/TNO/B&G, Leiden, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Heijungs, R. (1996): Identification of key issues for further investigationin improving the reliability of life-cycle assessments. J.Cleaner Prod. 4 (3/4) 159–166

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Hofstetter, P. (forthcoming): Perspectives in Life Cycle ImpactAssessment: A structured approach to combine models of thetechnosphere, ecosphere and valuesphere (Provisional title).Ph.D. thesis, ETH Zurich, Switzerland, expected publicationdate: autumn 1998

    Google Scholar 

  • Hunt, J. (1994): The social construction of precaution. In:O’Riordan, T. andJ. Cameron: Interpreting the precautionaryprinciple. Earthscan, London, UK

    Google Scholar 

  • IJC (International Joint Commission) (1993): A strategy for virtualelimination of persistent toxic substances. Volume 1 and2, Report of the Virtual Elimination Task Force to the International Joint Commission, Windsor, Ontario, Canada

  • ISIS (undated), Internationaal Stoffen Systeem. Versie 5.1.HASKONING, Nijmegen, Holland

  • IUCLID (1996): International Uniform Chemical Information Database, Existing Chemicals. European Chemical Bureau, European Commission-JRC, Environment Institute, Ispra (Italy)

    Google Scholar 

  • Jasanoff, S.S. (1987): Contested Boundaries in Policy-RelevantScience. Social Studies of Science, Vol. 17, 195–230

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Jasanoff, S.S. (1990): The fifth branch: Science Advisors asPolicymakers. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Jolliet, O. (1996): Impact assessment of human and eco-toxicityin life cycle assessment. In: Udo de Haes (1996)

  • Janus, J.A., J.M. Hesse, M.G.J. Rikken (eds.) (1994): Aandachtstoffenin het Nederlandse Milieubeleid overzicht 1994 [AttentionSubstances in the Dutch Environmental Policy - overview1994]. RIVM-report no. 601014006. Bilthoven, The Netherlands

    Google Scholar 

  • KemI (1991): Risk reduction of chemicals. Report 1991/1, KemI,Solna, Sweden

  • KemI (1994): Phthalic Acid Esters Used as Plastic Additives. Report1994/12 KemI, Solna, Sweden

  • Kleijn, R.,A. Tukker andE.V.D. Voet (1997): Chlorine in theNetherlands, part I: An Overview. Journal for Industrial Ecologynr. 1: 1

  • KlGuinöpifer, W. (1996): Reductionism versus Expansionism in LCA.Int. J. LCA 1 (2) 61

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Koeman, J.H.,H.A.J. Covers,W.A. Hafkamp,A. van der Meidenand H.J.W. Sas (1995): Peer review Guin“Closing the chlorinechainGuin”. Apeldoorn, 17 and 18 August 1995, In: Tukker et al.(1995)

  • Knorr-Cetina, K. (1985): Germ Warfare, review of: B.Latour,Les Microbes: guerre et paix suivi de Irreductions. Social Studies of Science, Vol. 15, 577–85

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Kuhn, T.S. (1962/1970): The structure of scientific revolutions.Dutch translation, Boom, Meppel, Holland

  • Latour, B. (1987): Science in action. Dutch translation 1995,Ooievaar Pockethouse, Amsterdam, Holland

  • Lkeuwfn, C.J. van (1995): General introduction. In:Leeuwen, C.J. van andJ.L.M. Hermens (eds.): Risk Assessment of Chemicals: An Introduction. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London

    Google Scholar 

  • Lindfors, L-G. (eds.) (1995): LCA-Nordic. Reports 1-9 and 10,TemaNord 1995:20, Nordic council of ministers, Copenhagen, Denmark

  • Lowenbach, W.A., R. Golden, E. Reese (1995): A model for estimatingBeef and Milk Bioconcentration Factors for DEHP. EnvironmentalRisk Sciences, Washington DC

    Google Scholar 

  • McCray, L.E. (1983): An anatomy of risk assessment: scientificand extra scientific components in the assessment of scientific data on cancer risks. In National Academy of Sciences: RiskAssessment in the Federal Government: Managing the process. Working papers, National Academy press, Washington DC, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • NCI (1995): Chloor op zijn plaats [Chlorine in the position itdeserves] and Risico’s van chloor beheersbaar [Risks of chlorinemanageable]. Journal of the Dutch Chemical Industry, 25 November 1995, Leidschendam, Holland

  • Owens, J.W. (1996): LCA Impact Assessment Categories. TechnicalFeasibility and Accuracy. Int. J. LCA 1 (3) 151–158

    CAS  Google Scholar 

  • Pinch, T.J. (1981): The Sun-Set: The presentation of Certainty inScientific Life. Social Studies of Science, Vol.11, 131–58

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Rip, A. (1986): Controversies as Informal Technology Assessment.Knowledge Vol. 8 No. 2, pp. 349–371

    Google Scholar 

  • Rip, A. (1992): Risicocontroverses en de verwevenheid vanwetenschap en politiek [Controversies about Risks and the Linksbetween Science and Politics]. Kennis en Methode 1992/1

  • Rotmans, J., M.B.A. van Asselt, A.J. De Bruin, M.G.J, den Elzen, J. De Greef, H. Hilderink, A.Y. Hoekstra, M.A. Janssen, H.W. Koster, W.J.M. Martens, L.W. Niessen, de H.J.M. Vries (1994): Global change and sustainable development, a modelling perspectivefor the next decade. Report 461502004, RIVM, Bilthoven, The Netherlands

    Google Scholar 

  • Rotmans, J. andH.J.M. de Vries (eds.) (1997): Perspectives onglobal futures: The TARGETS approach. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

    Google Scholar 

  • Shackley, S. andB. Wynne (1995): Mutual Construction — Globalclimate change: the mutual construction of an emergent science-policydomain. Science and Public Policy, Vol. 22, No. 4, pp. 218–230

    Google Scholar 

  • Sluijs, J.V.D. (1997): Anchoring amid uncertainty. On the managementof uncertainties in risk assessment of anthropogenicclimate change. Ph.D. thesis, University of Utrecht, Utrecht, the Netherlands

    Google Scholar 

  • Sluijs, J.V.D. andK. Schulte-Fishedick (1997): Omgaan metonzekerheden in wetenschap voor (milieu)beleid. Eeninventarisatie van theorieen en aanpakken [Dealing with uncertaintyin (environmental) policy. An inventory of theories andapproaches. Rathenau Instituut, The Hague, The Netherlands

    Google Scholar 

  • Smithson, M. (1993): Ignorance and Science. Knowledge Vol. 15No. 2, 133–156

    Google Scholar 

  • Staples C.A.,D.R. Peterson,T.F. Parkerton andW.J. Adams(1996): A literature review: The environmental fate of phthalateesters. Submitted to Chemosphere

  • Thompson, M. (1984): Among the Energy Tribes: A CulturalFramework for the Analysis and Design for Energy Policy. PolicySciences 17, pp. 321–339

    Google Scholar 

  • Thompson, M., R. Ellis andA. Wildavsky (1990): Cultural theory.Westview press, Boulder, CO, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Tukker, A., R. Kleijn, E.V.D. Voet, M. Alkemade, J. Brouwer, H. de Groot, J. de Kontng, T. Pulles, E. Smeets andJ.J.D. van der Steen (1995):A chlorine balance for the Netherlands. Report95/40, TNO-STB and CML, Apeldoorn, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Tukker, A., R. Kleijn, L. van Oers andE. Smeets (1996): A PVCsubstance flow analysis for Sweden. TNO and CML, report96/48, Apeldoorn, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Tukker, A. andR. Kleijn (1996): Tentative LCA-normalisation datafor Sweden. TNO/CML, report 96/49, Apeldoorn, Holland

    Google Scholar 

  • Tukker, A.,R. Kleijn,E v.d. Voet andE. Smeets (1997): Chlorinein the Netherlands Part II: Risk management in uncertainty.Journal of Industrial Ecology Vol. 1, No. 2

  • Tukker, A.,R. Kleijn,L. van Oers andE. Smeets (1998): CombiningSFA and LCA: the Swedish PVC analysis. Journal ofIndustrial Ecology Vol. 1., no 4

  • Tukker, A. (forthcoming): Frames in the Toxicity Controversy.Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London.Expeced publication date: Autumn 1998. Also published asPh.D. Thesis, Tilburg University/TNO, The Netherlands

  • Vermeire, T.G.,M.E. van Apeldoorn,J.C. de Fouw,P.J.C.M. Jansen(1991): Voorstel voor de humaan-toxicologische onderbouwingvan C-(toetsings)waarden [Proposal for the human toxicologicalunderpinning of C (testing) values]. RIVM report no.725201005, Bilthoven

  • Vermeire, T. andP. van der Zandt (1995): Procedures of hazardand risk assessment. In:Leeuwen, C.J. van andJ.L.M. Hermens (eds.): Risk Assessment of Chemicals: An Introduction. KluwerAcademic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London, pp. 293–337

    Google Scholar 

  • Verschueren K. (1996), Handbook of Environmental Data onOrganic Chemicals. Van Nostrand Reinhold, USA

    Google Scholar 

  • Udo de Haes, H.A. (ed.) (1996): Towards a methodology for LifeCycle Impact Assessment. SETAC-Europe, Brussels, Belgium

    Google Scholar 

  • Udo de Haes, H.A. andN. Wrisberg (1997): LCANET — A StrategicResearch Programme for Life Cycle Impact Assessment.LCA Documents, Ecomed Publishers, Germany

    Google Scholar 

  • US EPA (1998): Chemical Hazard Data Availability Study. EPA’s1998 Baseline of Hazard Information that is Readily Avialableto the Public. EPA’s Office for Pollution Prevention and Toxics,Washington, USA (available at: www.epa.gov/opptintr/chemtest/hazchem.htmurl)

    Google Scholar 

  • Weinberg, A.M. (1972): Science and Trans-science. Minerva Vol. X Nr. 2, pp. 209-222

  • White, P., B. De Smet, H.A. Udo de Haes and R. Heijungs (1995): LCA Back on Track, But is it one track or two? LCA-News (SETAC Europe) 5 No 3 p. 2-4

  • Wynne, B. (ed.) (1987): Risk management and hazardous waste. Implementation and the Dialectics of Credibility. Springer-Verlag, Berlin/London

    Google Scholar 

  • Wynne, B. (1993): Uncertainty and environmental learning. In: T. Jackson (ed.): Clean Production Strategies. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton/Ann Arbor/London/Tokio

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. TNO Institute of Strategy, Technology and Policy, 2600 JA, 6030, Delft, The Netherlands

    Arnold Tukker

Authors
  1. Arnold Tukker
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Arnold Tukker.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Tukker, A. Uncertainty in life cycle impact assessment of toxic releases practical experiences - arguments for a reductionalistic approach?. Int. J. LCA 3, 246–258 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02979831

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02979831

Keywords

Search

Navigation