Abstract
A critical examination of Carol Gilligan's study of “psychological theory and women's development,” this essay begins by exploring her concerns about malebiased developmental theorizing. I consider in detail Gilligan's criticisms of Sigmund Freud and her own empirical studies of moral development, as they relate to the work of L. Kohlberg. After defending Freud to some degree, I propose various (less theoretical but intuitively plausible) alternative interpretations of her data-interviews with males and females about hypothetical ethical dilemmas and with females about actual abortion decisions. I contend that Gilligan is too willing to concede the adequacy of Kohlberg's categories for fathoming the moral reasoning of males and that she may, in consequence, exaggerate differences between males and females. Noting the ironic similarities between Gilligan's claims and Schopenhauer's misogyny, I suggest that there may be something undesirably self-limiting about the ‘different’ course of development she sketches. To move toward a morally preferable, feminism-compatible version of an “ethic of care,” I recommend that it be extended — by the imagination — beyond the ‘here and now’ and that it not be restricted to existing webs of personal relationships.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Chodorow, N.: 1978, The Reproduction of Mothering, University of California Press, Berkeley.
Cocteau, J.: 1963, The Infernal Machine and Other Plays, New Directions, N.Y.
Emerson, R.W.: 1841, ‘Self-Reliance’, in D.H. Gilman (ed.), Selected Writings of Ralph Waldo Emerson, NAL Penguin Inc., New York, 1965.
Fowler, R. (ed.): 1973, A Dictionary of Modern Critical Terms, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London and Boston.
Freud, S.: 1925, ‘Some Psychological Consequences of the Anatomical Distinction between the Sexes’, in J. Strachey (ed.), Sigmund Freud: Collected Papers, Vol. V, Basic Books, Inc., New York, 1959.
Freud, S.: 1931, ‘Female Sexuality’, in Collected Papers, Vol. V.
Gilligan, C.: 1982, In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Ibsen, H.: 1879, A Doll's House, in P. Watts (trans.), Ibsen Plays, Penguin Books, Hammondsworth, England.
Kohlberg, L.: 1981, The Philosophy of Moral Development, Harper and Row, San Francisco.
Levinson, D.J.: 1978, The Seasons of a Man's Life, Alfred A. Knopf, New York.
Molton, J.: 1977, ‘The Myth of the Neutral “Man”’, in M. Vetterling-Braggin et al. (ed.), Feminism and Philosophy, Littlefield, Adams and Co., Totowa, N.J.
Schopenhauer, A.: 1851, ‘On Women’, in R.J. Hollingdale (trans. and ed.), Arthur Schopenhauer: Essays and Aphorisms, Penguin Books, N.Y., 1970.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Senchuk, D.M. Listening to a different voice: A feminist critique of Gilligan. Studies in Philosophy and Education 10, 233–249 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00367746
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00367746