Abstract
The chapter examines independent external oversight bodies’ and parliaments’ role in the governance of police stops. Drawing on literature and primary sources, including official reports and data generated by this COST Action, the chapter analyses typical police stop situations that independent external bodies deal with and their policy recommendations. The need for accountable and transparent policing and its importance for police legitimacy have led to many jurisdictions establishing independent public oversight bodies. Some are completely, others partially, independent from the police and government. Complaints bodies are particularly important where criminal investigation is either not relevant or fails. Independent accountability bodies’ policy recommendations are particularly significant in relation to accountability and improving adherence to human rights. However, the impact of such recommendations on police practices is limited.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abdul-Rahman, L., Espín-Grau, H., Klaus, L., & Singelnstein, T. (2020). Experiencing racism and discrimination in the context of the use of force by the police. Second Interim Report on the Police Use of Excessive Force (KviAPol) Research Project. https://kviapol.uni-frankfurt.de/images/pdf/en/EN_KviAPol_Second_Interim_Report_.pdf. Accessed 04 September 2023.
Aden, H. (2013). Polizeibeauftragte und Beschwerdestellen in Deutschland. Erfolgsbedingungen und neue Trends in den Ländern. Vorgänge. Zeitschrift für Bürgerrechte und Gesellschaftspolitik, 42(4)(=issue 204), 10–20.
Aden, H. (2017). Police governance and parliamentary police oversight in Germany. In M. J. Aguja & H. Born (Eds.), The role of parliament in police governance: Lessons learned from Asia and Europe (pp. 121–145). The Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces, DCAF.
Aden, H. (2019). Unabhängige Polizeibeschwerdestellen und Polizeibeauftragte. In D. Kugelmann (Ed.), Polizei und Menschenrechte (pp. 170–183). Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung.
Aden, H., & Bosch, A. (2022). Unabhängige Kontrolle als Schutz vor Rassismus und Diskriminierung? In D. Hunold & T. Singelnstein (Eds.), Rassismus in der Polizei. Eine wissenschaftliche Bestandsaufnahme (pp. 729–742). Springer VS [Open Access: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-37133-3_33].
Aden, H., & Bosch, A. (2023). Unabhängige Polizeibeauftragte in Deutschland - auf dem Weg zum Standard? Ziele, Praktiken, Defizite und mögliche Beiträge zum Diskriminierungsschutz. Vorgänge. Zeitschrift für Bürgerrechte und Gesellschaftspolitik, 61(1–2) (= issue 237/238), 161–174.
Aden, H., Fährmann, J., Bosch, A., & Thurn, R. (2022). Police stops in Germany—Between legal rules and informal practices. Journal of Organizational Ethnography, 11(2), 116–131.
Aguja, M. J., & Born, H. (Eds.). (2017). The role of parliament in police governance: Lessons learned from Asia and Europe. The Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces, DCAF.
Amnesty International. (2010). Täter unbekannt. Mangelnde Aufklärung von mutmaßlichen Misshandlungen durch die Polizei in Deutschland. Amnesty International.
Amnesty International. (2019). Stellungnahme zum Gesetzentwurf der Grünen NRW zur Einrichtung eines/einer unabhängigen Polizeibeauftragten. https://www.amnesty.de/sites/default/files/2019-10/Amnesty-Stellungnahme-Gesetzentwurf-%20Polizeibeauftragter-NRW-Oktober2019.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Balsai, I. (2011). Balsai report—Investigation of police violence in the fall of 2006. https://www.parlament.hu/irom39/04277/04277.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Bégasse, N. (2012, October 16). Contrôles d'identité: Le Défenseur des droits plaide pour un récépissé a minima. 20 minutes. https://www.20minutes.fr/societe/1023400-20121016-controles-identite-defenseur-droits-plaide-recepisse-minima. Accessed 8 March 2023.
BFM TV. (2020, June 6). Violences policières: le Défenseur des droits Jacques Toubon assure avoir “demandé des sanctions, qui souvent ne viennent pas”. bfmtv.com. https://www.bfmtv.com/societe/violences-policieres-le-defenseur-des-droits-jacques-toubon-assure-avoir-demande-des-sanctions-qui-souvent-ne-viennent-pas_VN-202006080079.html. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Borredon, L. (2013, October 14). Le Défenseur des droits examine l’encadrement légal des contrôles d’identité. Le Monde. https://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2013/10/14/le-defenseur-des-droits-examine-l-encadrement-legal-des-controles-d-identite_3495298_3224.html. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Botta, J. (2022). Unabhängige Polizeibeauftragte. JuristenZeitung, 77(13), 664–672.
Brodeur, J.-P. (1984). La police: mythes et réalités. Criminologie, 17, 9–41.
DDD (Défenseur des droits). (2012). Rapport du Défenseur des droits relatif aux relations police/citoyens et aux contrôles d’identité. https://www.defenseurdesdroits.fr/fr/rapports/2012/08/rapport-relatif-aux-relations-policecitoyens-et-aux-controles-didentite. Accessed 8 March 2023.
DDD (Défenseur des droits). (2017). Relations police/population: le Défenseur des droits publie une enquête sur les contrôles d’identité. https://www.defenseurdesdroits.fr/fr/actus/actualites/relations-policepopulation-le-defenseur-des-droits-publie-une-enquete-sur-les. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Deutscher Bundestag. (2013). Beschlussempfehlungen und Bericht des 2. Untersuchungsausschuss nach Artikel 44 des Grundgesetzes. Drucksache 17/14600. Berlin.
Deutsches Institut für Menschenrechte. (2020). Racial Profiling: Bund und Länder müssen polizeiliche Praxis überprüfen. Stellungnahme zum Verbot rassistischer Diskriminierung, Juli 2020, Berlin. https://www.institut-fuer-menschenrechte.de/fileadmin/Redaktion/Publikationen/Stellungnahmen/Stellungnahme_Racial_Profiling_Bund_Laender_muessen_polizeil_Praxis_ueberpruefen.pdf. Accessed 21 March 2023.
(Die) Bürgerbeauftragte des Landes Baden-Württemberg. (2021). 4. Jahresbericht. 2020/2021, Stuttgart.
(Der) Bürgerbeauftragte des Landes Rheinland-Pfalz und der Beauftragte für die Landespolizei. (2017). Tätigkeitsbericht 2016–2017, Mainz.
(Die) Bürgerbeauftragte des Landes Rheinland-Pfalz und die Beauftragte für die Landespolizei. (2018). Tätigkeitsbericht 2017–2018, Mainz.
(Die) Bürgerbeauftragte des Landes Rheinland-Pfalz und die Beauftragte für die Landespolizei. (2019). Tätigkeitsbericht 2018–2019, Mainz.
(Die) Bürgerbeauftragte des Landes Rheinland-Pfalz und die Beauftragte für die Landespolizei. (2020). Tätigkeitsbericht 2019–2020, Mainz.
(Die) Beauftragte für die Landespolizei Schleswig-Holstein. (2020). Tätigkeitsbericht 2016–2018, Kiel.
(Die) Beauftragte für die Landespolizei Schleswig-Holstein. (2021). Tätigkeitsbericht 2018–2020, Kiel.
ECRI (European Commission Against Racism and Intolerance, Equality and Human Rights Commission). (2013). Report on Finland (fourth monitoring cycle). http://rm.coe.int/fourth-report-on-finland/16808b5714. Accessed 8 March 2023.
ECRI (European Commission Against Racism and Intolerance, Equality and Human Rights Commission). (2019). Report on Finland (fifth monitoring cycle). https://rm.coe.int/fifth-report-on-finland/1680972fa7. Accessed 8 March 2023.
EHRC (Equality and Human Rights Commission). (2013). Stop and think again—Towards race equality in police PACE stop and search. https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/race-britain/stop-and-think-again. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Espín Grau, H., Piening, M.-T., & Singelnstein, T. (2022). Police accountability: Neue Perspektiven auf Fehlerkultur, demokratische Einhegung und Kontrolle der Polizei. Neue Kriminalpolitik, 34(2), 2–17.
Flanagan, R. (2008). The Independent review of policing—Final Report. London: Home Office. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/media/flanagan-review-of-policing-20080201.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Floux, F. (2016, June 30). Pourquoi le récepissé pour les contrôles d'identité a été enterré. 20 minutes. https://www.20minutes.fr/societe/1877715-20160630-pourquoi-recepisse-controles-identite-enterre. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Fodor-Lukács, K. (2011). A Független Rendészeti Panasztestület elmúlt három évének tapasztalatairól. Rendészet és emberi jogok, 3(1), 71–91. http://epa.niif.hu/02200/02222/00003/pdf/EPA_02218_ReEJ_2011_03.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
franceinfo. (2021, February 16). Plateforme anti-discriminations: “L'objectif est de résoudre le problème des personnes”, affirme la Défenseure des droits. franceinfo. https://www.francetvinfo.fr/societe/racisme/plateforme-anti-discriminations-l-objectif-est-de-resoudre-le-probleme-des-personnes-affirme-la-defenseure-des-droits_4294083.html. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HE. (2014). Hallituksen esitys eduskunnalle laiksi ulkomaalaislain muuttamisesta (The government proposal for a law to change the Aliens Act) HE 169/2014 vp.
Himanen, M. (2021). An ambiguous ban on ethnic profiling: Reforming immigration law enforcement at the juncture of non-discrimination norms and migration control. Nordic Journal of Studies in Policing, 8(2), 1–18.
HMIC (Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary). (2013). Stop and search powers: Are the police using them effectively and fairly? https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/media/stop-and-search-powers-20130709.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMIC (Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary). (2013, July 8). Press release—HMIC finds the police use of stop and search powers is too often ineffective in tackling crime and procedurally incorrect, thereby threatening the legitimacy of the police. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/news/releases/0202013-hmic-finds-the-police-use-of-stop-and-search-powers-is-too-often-ineffective/. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMICFRS (His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services). (2015). Stop and search powers 2. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/publications/stop-and-search-powers-2-are-the-police-using-them-effectively-and-fairly/. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMICFRS (His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services). (2016a). PEEL: Police legitimacy 2015: A national overview. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/wp-content/uploads/peel-police-legitimacy-2015.pdf. (See also individual reports at https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/publications/police-legitimacy-2015/). Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMICFRS (His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services). (2016b). Best use of stop and search scheme. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/wp-content/uploads/best-use-of-stop-and-search-scheme.pdf. See also force letters at https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/publications/best-use-of-stop-and-search-revisits/. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMICFRS (His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services). (2021). Disproportionate use of police powers: A spotlight on stop and search and the use of force. https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/wp-content/uploads/disproportionate-use-of-police-powers-spotlight-on-stop-search-and-use-of-force.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
HMICS. (2014). Audit and assurance review of stop and search: Phase 1. https://www.hmics.scot/sites/default/files/publications/HMICS%20-%20Audit%20and%20Assurance%20Review%20of%20Stop%20and%20Search%20-%20Phase%201_0.pdf. Accessed 08 March 2023.
HMICS. (2017). Audit and assurance review of stop and search: Phase 2. https://www.hmics.scot/sites/default/files/publications/HMICS%20Audit%20and%20Assurance%20Review%20of%20Stop%20and%20Search%20Phase%202.pdf
Home Affairs Committee. (1980). Race relations and the “Sus” law—Second Report 1979–80.
Home Affairs Committee. (2005). Terrorism and community relations—Sixth Report of Session 2004–05. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/272140/6593.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Home Affairs Committee. (2007). Young Black People and the criminal justice system—Second Report of Session 2006–07. https://dera.ioe.ac.uk/6506/1/181i.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Home Affairs Committee. (2009). The Macpherson report—Ten years on—Twelfth report of Session 2008–09. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmselect/cmhaff/427/427.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Home Office. (2014). Best use of stop and search scheme. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/346922/Best_Use_of_Stop_and_Search_Scheme_v3.0_v2.pdf. Accessed 08 March 2023.
Home Office. (2022). Stop and search summary data tables. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1113377/stop-search-data-tables-summary-mar22.ods. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Humanistische Union. (Ed.). (1975). Demokratischer Rechtsstaat zwischen individuellem Terror und Polizeigewalt. Dokumentation über die Fahndungsmaßnahmen im Zusammenhang mit der Lorenz-Entführung. Internationale Liga für Menschenrechte und Humanistische Union Landesverband Berlin.
Humanistische Union. (2013). Gesetzentwurf zur Institutionalisierung eines Polizeibeauftragten. Vorgänge. Zeitschrift für Bürgerrechte und Gesellschaftspolitik, 52(4) (= issue 204), 51–58.
Hungarian IPCB. (2008). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906327/2008_tajekoztato.pdf/60a01c21-83ec-00cf-a2bf-9e58623bcd5c?version=1.0&t=1617903044019. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2009). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906303/T%C3%A1j%C3%A9koztat%C3%B3+2009+v%C3%A9gleges_sk.pdf/493afa97-0937-3736-810d-ef766d0a5f7f?version=1.0&t=1617902986545. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2010). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906279/2010_tajekoztato.pdf/7dacbcb9-69f4-ac10-ffd0-be710f9d874d?version=1.0&t=1617902929985. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2011). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906191/2011.+%C3%A9vi+T%C3%81J%C3%89KOZTAT%C3%93+V%C3%89GLEGES+2012.12.05..pdf/8e604b03-8345-1127-11f3-11f106d9507b?version=1.0&t=1617902886831. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2012). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906167/FRP+2012.+%C3%A9vi+T%C3%A1j%C3%A9koztat%C3%B3ja+PDF.pdf/d8351950-a49d-e155-5240-5190e2c7a775?version=1.0&t=1617902779839. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2013). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3906106/FRP_2013evi_Tajekoztatoja+statisztik%C3%A1val+-+v%C3%A9gleges.pdf/725cf16f-910c-d568-1c62-1674a5efe588?version=1.0&t=1617902704813. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2014). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905789/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2014_2_aa.pdf/0209669e-1cfb-fb50-987f-a6cdf70bcdd8?version=1.0&t=1617902679419. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2015). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905772/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2015+v%C3%A9gleges.pdf/8bf84f93-58f6-b019-6900-27cc8b265217?version=1.0&t=1617902077201b. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2016). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905748/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2016.pdf/09fdb7cf-8e29-9c8c-5b2c-ae33fac913e9?version=1.0&t=1617901985592. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2017). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905705/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2017.pdf/88ce788a-78b2-3f4d-8b26-4068f8f09991?version=1.0&t=1617901810071. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2018). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905702/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2018.pdf/640cc0cc-8d5f-34df-711e-2abe675c9ed2?version=1.0&t=1617901904190. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian IPCB. (2019). Annual report. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/10180/3905684/FRP+tajekoztato+es+statisztika+2019.pdf/667ab845-d394-71d1-72a1-b36b47c88677?version=1.0&t=1617892066167. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Hungarian Parliament. (2012). Resolution 17/2012. (III. 14.).
Hungarian sub-committee. (2010). Report on the violation of human rights between 2002–2010. https://2010-2014.kormany.hu/download/2/28/00000/jelentes.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
hvg.hu (2012). 2006-os zavargások: elfogadták a Balsai-jelentést, HVG 2012. március 12. https://hvg.hu/itthon/20120312_balsai_jel_elf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC). (2020). Thematic stop and search learning recommendations’. https://www.policeconduct.gov.uk/sites/default/files/Documents/investigation_reports/Stop%20and%20Search%20-%20Response%20to%20IOPC%20Learning%20Recommendations.pdf. Accessed 8 May 2023.
Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC). (2009). IPCC position regarding police powers to stop and search. London: IPCC.
IOPC. (2021). Police complaints: Statistics for England and Wales. https://www.policeconduct.gov.uk/research-and-learning/statistics/police-complaints-statistics. Accessed 8 March 2023.
IOPC. (2022). Thematic stop and search learning recommendations. https://www.policeconduct.gov.uk/sites/default/files/Documents/publications/OFFICIAL%20IOPC%20National%20stop%20and%20search%20learning%20report%2020%20April%202022.pdf. Accessed 8 May 2023.
IOPC. (2023). ‘Annual report and statement of accounts: 2021/22’.
Keskinen, S., & Himanen, M. (2023, forthcoming). Human rights, criminalisation of migrants and racism debates: Public discussions about police stops and ethnic profiling in Finland. In J. de Maillard, M. Rowe, & K. Verfaillie (Eds.), The politicization of police stops in Europe: Public issues and police reform. Palgrave Macmillan.
Macpherson, W. (1999). The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry. London: HMSO.
Murray, K., & Harkin, D. (2017). Policing in cool and hot climates: Legitimacy, power and the rise and fall of mass stop and search in Scotland. British Journal of Criminology, 57(4), 885–905.
Nenonen, T., Kivelä, J., Ervasti, E., Joronen, M., & Villa, S. (2021). Perusoikeusbarometri. Oikeusministeriön julkaisuja, Selvityksiä ja ohjeita. Oikeusministeriö. http://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-952-259-821-9. Accessed 16 March 2023.
Northern Ireland Policing Board. (2013). The use of police powers to stop and search and stop and question under the Terrorism Act 2000 and Justice and Security (NI) Act 2007.
Office of the Commissioner for Fundamental Rights. (2021). Report on the activities of the commissioner for fundamental rights of Hungary and his deputies 2020. https://www.ajbh.hu/documents/14315/4142668/Report+on+the+Activities+of+the+Commissioner+for+Fundamental+Rights+of+Hungary+and+his+Deputies+2020.pdf/b4b025a0-e2a7-7cdc-05c1-23cfdc198767?version=1.0&t=1626438831628. Accessed 8 March 2023.
O’Neill, M., & Aston, E. (2018). Changing stop and search in Scotland. European Journal of Policing Studies, 5(4), 129–152.
Philips, C. (1981). Report of the Royal Commission on criminal procedure. Cmnd 8092. https://www.ucpi.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/royal_commission_on_criminal_procedure-report.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Piening, M.-T., Kühne, M., & Töpfer, E. (2022). Parlamentarische Polizeibeauftragte: Vermittlungs- statt Ermittlungsstellen. Bürgerrechte & Polizei/CILIP, 130, 17–28.
Police Ombusdman of Northern Ireland (PONI). (2022). Annual Bulletin. https://www.policeombudsman.org/Statistics-and-Research/Complaint-Statistics-in-Northern-Ireland. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Police Scotland Professional Standards. (2021). Quarterly performance report: Q1 20/21. https://www.spa.police.uk/spa-media/4fhkaaao/rep-c-20200820-item-8-police-scotland-professional-standards-quarterly-performance-re.pdf. Accessed 8 March 2023.
Scarman, L. (1981). Brixton disorders 10–12 April 1981. London: HSMO.
Scott, J. (2015). The report of the Advisory group on stop and search. Scottish Government.
Scottish Police Authority. (2014). Scrutiny review: Police Scotland’s stop and search policy and practice.
Skolnick, J. H., & Fyfe, J. J. (1993). Above the law: Police and the excessive use of force. Simon & Schulster.
UNODC (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime). (2011). Handbook on police accountability, oversight and integrity. United Nations.
Vuorensyrjä, M., & Rauta, R. (2020). Poliisibarometri 2020. Kansalaisten arviot poliisin toiminnasta ja Suomen sisäisen turvallisuuden tilasta. Sisäministeriö. http://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-952-324-641-6. Accessed 16 March 2023.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Dr Anja Johansen (University of Dundee) and the members of the Police Stops COST Action Working Group on the Governance of Police Stops for their input and feedback
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2024 The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Aden, H. et al. (2024). External Accountability: The Limited Influence of Oversight Bodies on the Governance of Police Stops. In: Aston, E., De Kimpe, S., Fazekas, J., Lennon, G., Rowe, M. (eds) Governing Police Stops Across Europe. Palgrave's Critical Policing Studies. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-41363-6_4
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-41363-6_4
Published:
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-031-41362-9
Online ISBN: 978-3-031-41363-6
eBook Packages: Law and CriminologyLaw and Criminology (R0)