Abstract
Voice quality outcome becomes an important factor in the choice of the therapeutic option. The differences between radiotherapy and laser cordectomy have been extensively debated in the literature. We analyzed the vocal outcomes after carbon dioxide (CO2) laser cordectomy and radiotherapy treatment for T1a-b early glottic cancer by means of objective and subjective voice evaluation. A retrospective study was performed on 56 cancer patients, 30 treated with cordectomy and 26 with radiotherapy. All patients underwent laser cordectomy which was performed under general anesthesia using a surgical microscope in laryngeal suspension. The laser we used was an Ultrapulse one, 10.6-μm wavelength, and a power setting of 2 to 4 W in an Ultrapulse mode was selected. Two different sets of data were recorded: (a) voice acoustic analysis (jitter, shimmer, fundamental frequency and noise/harmonic ratio) and (b) voice handicap index (VHI). Data collected were statistically analyzed using SPSS 20.0 for Windows. Jitter, shimmer, and signal-to-noise ratio were significantly altered in both glottic cancer patient groups as compared to the control group. On the contrary, no statistically significant alteration of the fundamental frequency was found in both treatment groups. Interestingly, jitter and shimmer values were significantly more compromised in transoral laser surgery patients as compared with radiotherapy-treated patients. The VHI was also significantly altered in both cancer patient groups as compared to the control group. More importantly, however, the self-evaluation voice analysis was not significantly different between the two treatment groups, contrary to what we observed for two of the four parameters measured in the objective voice analysis. Given the importance of the self-perception of the voice quality, no treatment can be considered superior from the patients’ point of view. Therefore, we suggest that priority should be given to the endoscopic surgery, due to lower costs, lower morbidity, and shorter hospitalization.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Peretti G, Piazza C, Mora F, Garofolo S, Guastini L (2016) Reasonable limits for transoral laser microsurgery in laryngeal cancer. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 24:135–139
Wilkie MD, Lightbody KA, Lythgoe D, Tandon S, Lancaster J, Jones TM (2015) Transoral laser microsurgery for early and moderately advanced laryngeal cancers: outcomes from a single centralised United Kingdom centre. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 272:695–704
Abdurehim Y, Hua Z, Yasin Y, Xukurhan A, Imam I, Yuqin F (2012) Transoral laser surgery versus radiotherapy: systematic review and meta-analysis for treatment options of T1a glottic cancer. Head Neck 34:23–33
Motta G, Esposito E, Motta S, Tartaro G, Testa D (2005) CO2 laser surgery in the treatment of glottic cancer. Head Neck 27:733
Motta S, Cesari U, Mesolella M, Motta G (2008) Functional vocal results after CO2 laser endoscopic surgery for glottic tumours. J Laryngol Otol 122:948–951
Peretti G, Piazza C, Balzanelli C, Cantarella G, Nicolai P (2003) Vocal outcome after endoscopic cordectomies for Tis and T1 glottic carcinomas. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 112:174–179
Stomeo F, Tosin E, Morolli F, Bianchini C, Ciorba A, Pastore A, Pelucchi S (2013) Comparison of subjective and objective tools in transoral laser cordectomy for early glottic cancer: importance of voice handicap index. Int J Immunopathol Pharmacol 26:445–451
Maurizi M, Almadori G, Plaudetti G, De Corso E, Galli J (2005) Laser carbon dioxide cordectomy versus open surgery in the treatment of glottic carcinoma: our results. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 132:857–861
Iengo M, Villari P, Masula I, De Clemente M (2000) CO2 laser cordectomy: analysis of morpho-functional results. Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital 20:106–120
Canis M, Ihler F, Martin A, Matthias C, Steiner W (2014) Transoral laser microsurgery for T1a glottic cancer: review of 404 cases. Head Neck 37:889–895
Hartl DM, Ferlito A, Brasnu DF, Langendijk JA, Rinaldo A, Silver CE, Wolf GT (2011) Evidence-based review of treatment options for patients with glottic cancer. Head Neck 33:1638–1648
Mendenhall WM, Parsons JT, Stringer SP, Cassisi NJ, Million RR (1988) T1-T2 vocal cord carcinoma: a basis for comparing the results of radiotherapy and surgery. Head and Neck Surg 10:373–377
Spector JG, Session DG, Chao KS et al (1999) Stage I (T1 N0 M0) squamous cell carcinoma of the laryngeal glottis: therapeutic results and voice preservation. Head Neck 21:707–717
Viani L, Stell PM, Dalby JE (1991) Recurrence after radiotherapy for glottic carcinoma. Cancer 67:577–584
Krengli M, Policarpo M, Manfredda I, Aluffi P, Gambaro G, Panella M, Pia F (2004) Voice quality after treatment for T1a glottic carcinoma radiotherapy versus laser cordectomy. Acta Oncol 43:284–289
Moose BD, Greven KM (1997) Definitive radiation management for carcinoma of the glottic larynx. Otolaryngol Clin N Am 30:131–143
Sewnaik A, van den Brink JL, Wieringa MH, Meeuwis CA, Kerrebijn JD (2005) Surgery for recurrent laryngeal carcinoma after radiotherapy: partial laryngectomy or total laryngectomy for a better quality of life? Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 132:95–98
Markou K, Nikolaou A, Nalbadian M, Petridis D, Nicolaidis V, Daniilidis I (2002) How often is total laryngectomy necessary for the treatment of T1 failures after radiotherapy or cordectomy? Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 259:4–10
Warner L, Chudasama J, Kelly CG, Loughran S, McKenzie K, Wight R, Dey P (2014) Radiotherapy versus open surgery versus endolaryngeal surgery (with or without laser) for early laryngeal squamous cell cancer. Cochrane Ear, Nose and Throat Disorders Group
Serra A, Maiolino L, Di Mauro P, Licciardello L, Cocuzza S (2016) The senile functional evolution of the larynx after supracricoid reconstructive surgery. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 273:4359–4368
Sjögren EV, van Rossum MA, Langeveld TP (2008) Voice outcome in T1a midcord glottic carcinoma: laser surgery vs radiotherapy. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 134:965–972
Goor KM, Peeters AJ, Mahieu HF, Langendijk JA, Leemans CR, Verdonck-de Leeuw IM, van Agthoven M (2007) Cordectomy by CO2 laser or radiotherapy for small T1a glottic carcinomas: costs, local control, survival, quality of life, and voice quality. Head Neck 29:128–136
Loughran S, Calder N, MacGregor FB, Carding P, MacKenzie K (2005) Quality of life and voice following endoscopic resection or radiotherapy for early glottic cancer. Clin Otolaryngol 30:42–47
Remmelts AJ, Hoebers FJ, Klop WM, Balm AJ, Hamming-Vrieze O, van den Brekel MW (2013) Evaluation of laser surgery and radiotherapy as treatment modalities in early stage laryngeal carcinoma: tumour outcome and quality of voice. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 270:2079–2087
Núñez Batalla F, Caminero Cueva MJ, Señaris González B, Llorente Pendás JL, Gorriz Gil C, López Llames A, Alonso Pantiga R, Suárez Nieto C (2008) Voice quality after endoscopic laser surgery and radiotherapy for early glottic cancer: objective measurements emphasizing the voice handicap index. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 265:543–548
Dinapoli N, Parrilla C, Galli J, Autorino R, Miccichè F, Bussu F, Balducci M, D’Alatri L, Marchese R, Rigante M, Di Lella G, Liberati L, Almadori G, Paludetti G, Valentini V (2010) Multidisciplinary approach in the treatment of T1 glottic cancer. Strahlenther Onkol 186:607–613
Jotic A, Stankovic P, Jesic S, Milovanovic J, Stojanovic M, Djukic V (2012) Voice quality after treatment of early glottic carcinoma. J Voice 26:381–389
Tomifuji M, Araki K, Niwa K, Miyagawa Y, Mizokami D, Kitagawa Y, Yamashita T, Matsunobu T, Shiotani A (2013) Comparison of voice quality after laser cordectomy with that after radiotherapy or chemoradiotherapy for early glottic carcinoma. ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec 75:18–26
Rydell R, Schalén L, Fex S, Elner A (1995) Voice evaluation before and after laser excision vs. radiotherapy of T1A glottic carcinoma. Acta Otolaryngol 115:560–565
Aaltonen LM, Rautiainen N, Sellman J, Saarilahti K, Mäkitie A, Rihkanen H, Laranne J, Kleemola L, Wigren T, Sala E, Lindholm P, Grenman R, Joensuu H (2014) Voice quality after treatment of early vocal cord cancer: a randomized trial comparing laser surgery with radiation therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 90:255–260
Laoufi S, Mirghani H, Janot F, Hartl DM (2014) Voice quality after treatment of T1a glottic cancer. Laryngoscope 124:1398–1401
Remacle M, Van Haverbeke C, Eckel H, Bradley P, Chevalier D, Djukic V, de Vicentiis M, Friedrich G, Olofsson J, Peretti G, Quer M, Werner J (2007) Proposal for revision of the European Laryngological Society classification of endoscopic cordectomies. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 264:499–504
Rovirosa A, Martínez-Celdrán E, Ortega A, Ascaso C, Abellana R, Velasco M, Bonet M, Herrera C, Casas F, Francisco RM, Arenas M, Hernández V, Sánchez-Reyes A, León C, Traserra J, Biete A (2000) Acoustic analysis after radiotherapy in T1 vocal cord carcinoma: a new approach to the analysis of voice quality. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys 47:73–79
Verdonck-de Leeuw IM, Hilgers FJ, Keus RB, Koopmans-van Beinum FJ, Greven AJ, de Jong JM, Vreeburg G, Bartelink H (1999) Multidimensional assessment of voice characteristics after radiotherapy for early glottic cancer. Laryngoscope 109:241–248
Lehman J, Bless D, Brandeburg J, Brandenburg JH (1998) An objective assessment of voice production after radiation therapy for stage I squamous cell carcinoma of the glottis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 98:121–129
Dagli AS, Mahieu HF, Festen JM (1997) Quantitative analysis of voice quality in early glottic laryngeal carcinomas treated with radiotherapy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 254:78–80
Luo CM, Fang TJ, Lin CY, Chang JT, Liao CT, Chen IH, Li HY, Chiang HC (2012) Transorallaser microsurgery elevates fundamental frequency in early glottic cancer. J Voice 26:596–601
Aref A, Dworkin J, Devi S, Denton L, Fontanesi J (1997) Objective evaluation of the quality of voice following radiation therapy for T1 glottic cancer. Radiother Oncol 45:149–153
Du G, Liu C, Yu W, Li J, Li W, Wang C, Zhu J (2015) Voice outcomes after laser surgery vs. radiotherapy of early glottic carcinoma: a meta-analysis. Int J Clin Exp Med 8:17206–17213
Greulich MT, Parker NP, Lee P, Merati AL, Misono S (2015) Voice outcomes following radiation versus laser microsurgery for T1 glottic carcinoma: systematic review and meta-analysis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 152:811–819
Cohen SM, Garrett CG, Dupont WD, Ossoff RH, Courey MS (2006) Voice-related quality of life in T1 glottic cancer: irradiation versus endoscopic excision. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 115:581–586
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Ethical approval
This study received approval from the ethics committee of the “Magna Graecia” University of Catanzaro, “Regione Calabria” (approval number 219).
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Informed consent
Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lombardo, N., Aragona, T., Alsayyad, S. et al. Objective and self-evaluation voice analysis after transoral laser cordectomy and radiotherapy in T1a-T1b glottic cancer. Lasers Med Sci 33, 141–147 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-017-2361-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-017-2361-0