Abstract
Despite many studies on Chinese representations of the European Union (EU), limited attention has been given to how this is shaped by the EU’s trade policy. This article considers recent developments in EU trade policy, in the context of China’s rise as an economic power and the EU’s labelling of China as a systemic rival. Using a reversed analytical framework of actorness, this article shows how the EU’s trade policies are represented by the Chinese official media and intellectual elites. Our thematic analysis centres on these two types of Chinese social actors’ discourses about EU trade from January 2013 to July 2021. The findings reveal that their representations of the EU’s trade actorness highlight (i) the EU’s importance with regard to China’s competition with the US, (ii) the EU’s decreasing normative attractiveness for China due to its institutional and ideational incapability, and (iii) China’s positive expectations for EU-China relations in the future with China’s own active efforts. This research also contributes a nuanced approach in analysing the relevance of Chinese social actors’ representations for China’s foreign policy making.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Braun, V., and V. Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3 (2): 77–101.
Bretherton, C., and J. Vogler. 2006. The European Union as a global actor, 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
Bretherton, C., and J. Vogler. 2013. A global actor past its peak? International Relations 27 (3): 375–390.
Chaban, N., and M. Holland, eds. 2018. Sha** the EU global strategy: Partners and perceptions. Springer.
Chai, Y. (2013) ‘The EU’s anti dum** and anti-subsidy towards China harm others without benefit itself’, People’s Web, 23rd May.
Chang, V.K., and F.N. Pieke. 2018. Europe’s engagement with China: Shifting Chinese views of the EU and the EU-China relationship. Asia Europe Journal 16 (4): 317–331.
Chen, Z.M. 2012. Europe as a global player: A view from China. Perspectives: Review of Central European Affairs 20: 7–29.
Dai, B., and S. Zhang. 2007. EU perceptions in China. In The EU through the eyes of Asia: Media, public and elite perceptions in China, Japan, Korea Singapore and Thailand, ed. M. Holland, et al., 43–67. Singapore and Warsaw: University of Warsaw Press.
Dong, L., ed. 2012. Chinese views of the EU; latest data, contributing factors and policy implications. Bei**g: Social Sciences Academic Press.
Dong, L. 2014. Chinese perceptions of the European Union. Journal of Contemporary China 23 (88): 756–779.
European Commission, 2005. Visibility strategy study—Focus group analysis of perceptions of the EU in China. 31 May 2005.
European Commission, 2015. Trade for all: Towards a more responsible trade and investment policy, 14th Oct.
European Commission, 2019. EU-China—A strategic outlook, 12th Mar.
European Commission. 2021. Trade policy review—An open, sustainable and assertive trade policy, 18th Feb.
Fairclough, N. 2003. Analysing discourse: Textual analysis for social research. Psychology Press.
Fang, Y.X., and X.B. Wang. 2018. ‘The US imposing taxes on steel and aluminum shocks global multilateral trade system’. People’s Daily, 2nd June.
Foreign Ministry of People’s Republic of China (FMPRC). 2003. China’s EU Policy Paper, 13th October.
Foreign Ministry of People’s Republic of China (FMPRC). 2014. China's policy paper on the EU: Deepen the China EU comprehensive strategic partnership for mutual benefit and Winwin Cooperation, 2nd April.
Foreign Ministry of People’s Republic of China (FMPRC). 2018. China's Policy Paper on the European Union, December.
Freeman, D. 2021. The EU and China: Policy perceptions of economic cooperation and competition. Asia Europe Journal 20: 245–264.
Geeraerts, G. 2007. In the eyes of the dragon: Chinese perceptions of the EU as a Global Actor. Biccs Asia Paper.
Hervé, A. 2021. The European trade policy in the time of Covid-19: adaptation or change of paradigm? European Issue n°581, Robert Schuman Center.
Ji, Z.C. 2019. ‘The EU’s policy choice in the China-US trade conflict. Studies of International Relations 1: 77.
Jiang, X.H. 2013. An analysis of the new development of the EU’s trade defense reform. European Studies 6: 78.
Jiang, J.X. 2021. ‘EU's promotion of “carbon tariffs” triggers controversy’. People’s Daily, 22nd July.
Joffe, H. 2012. Thematic analysis. Qualitative Research Methods in Mental Health and Psychotherapy: A Guide for Students and Practitioners 1: 210–223.
Jørgensen, M.W., and L.J. Phillips. 2002. Discourse analysis as theory and method. Sage.
Jupille, J., and J.A. Caporaso. 1998. States, agency and rules: The European Union in global environmental politics. In The European Union in the world community, ed. C. Rhodes, 213–229. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
Klose, S. 2018. Theorizing the EU’s actorness: Towards an interactionist role theory framework. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 56 (5): 1144–1160.
Knops, L., and B. De Cleen. 2019. The radical right versus the media: From media critique to claims of (mis) representation. Politics and Governance 7 (3): 165–178.
Lai, S.Y. 2018. Trajectories and transformations: Relations and perceptions of the EU in China, 2006–2015. In Sha** the EU global strategy: Partners and perceptions, ed. N. Chaban and M. Holland, 77–100. Springer.
Lai, S.Y., and Z. Shi. 2017. How China views the EU in global energy governance: A norm exporter, a partner or an outsider? Comparative European Politics 15 (1): 80–98.
Lai, S.Y., and L. Zhang. 2013. Challenging the EU’s economic roles? The impact of the Eurozone crisis on EU images in China. Baltic Journal of European Studies 3 (3): 13–36.
Li, X. 2007. Chinese television coverage and Chinese perceptions of Sino-EU relations. In The international politics of EU-China relations, ed. D. Ker and F. Liu, 102–117. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Li, X.X. 2017. Labor standards in EU free trade agreement and its enlightenment. Law Science 1: 105.
Li, Y.Y. 2017. The compatibility of the EU’s anti-dum** law and the WTO multilateral rules. Journal of Law Application 11: 55.
Li, Y.Q., and K.J. Guan. 2016. The EU-US FTA negotiations enter a deadlock. People’s Daily, 2nd September.
Liang, L.L., and X.N. Zhao. 2016. ‘The EU’s new trade anti-dum** will do nothing good to the Chinese companies. People’s Web, 25th July.
Liu, M.L. 2018. An analysis of the EU’s contradictory attitude to globalization. Modern International Relations 7: 39.
Liu, X.H. 2018. ‘A research on the new paradigm of global trade regulatory cooperation in TTIP and Chinese Reaction. Journal of Shanghai University of Finance and Economics 20 (5): 139.
Lucarelli, S. 2014. Seen from the outside: The state of the art on the external image of the EU. Journal of European Integration 36 (1): 1–16.
Luo, Y.F., and Y.D. Hua. 2013. Trade protectionism: Harm whose feet by lifting the stone. **nhua web, 6th June.
McMahon, R., and H.S. Liu. 2023. Introduction to this special issue. Comparative European Politics. Forthcoming.
Men, J. 2006. Chinese perceptions of the European Union: A review of leading Chinese journals. European Law Journal 12 (6): 788–806.
Möller, K. 2002. Diplomatic relations and mutual strategic perceptions: China and the European Union. The China Quarterly 169: 10.
Pepermans, A. 2017. The Sino-European solar panel dispute: China’s successful carrot and stick approach towards Europe. Journal of Contemporary European Research 13 (4): 1394–1411.
Pitkin, H.F. 1967. The concept of representation. University of California Press.
PPMI (Public Policy and Management Institute), NCRE (National Centre for Research on Europe), and NFG Research Group. 2015. Analysis of the perceptions of the EU and EU’s policies abroad: Annex II—Integrated literature review and current practices in EU public diplomacy. Brussels: European Commission.
Rhinard, M., and G. Sjöstedt. 2019. The EU as a global actor: A new conceptualisation five decades after “actorness”. UI Paper No, 6.
Schilling, E. 2012. When the rising dragon sees fading stars: China’s view of the European Union. CEPS Special Report, No.73. Brussels: CEPS.
Shi, Y. 2019. The EU pushes the WTO reform: Claim, approach and influence. Studies on International issues 2: 82.
Sjöstedt, G. 1977. The external role of the European Community. Farnborough: Saxon House.
Smith, K.E. 2005. Beyond the civilian power EU debate. Politique Européene, Autumn 17: 63–82.
Song, X.X., and L. Min. 2015. The newest progress of TTIP negotiation and China’s strategy. International Commerce Studies. 36 (202): 66.
Tan, B.Y. 2013. Watch out the EU taking antidum** and anti-subsidy measures to the Chinese solar panel products as a trade leverage. People’s Web, 5th June.
Tang, H. 2011. Analysis of focus group interview data: a report of ‘Chinese views of EU’, international conference on “Chinese view of the EU: disaggregating Chinese perceptions of the EU and the implications for the EU’s China policy”. London: Chatham House
van Loon, P. 2014. Chinese perceptions: An exploration into the non-material underpinning of Sino–EU trade relations. In Europe and Asia: Perceptions from Afar, ed. M. Holland and N. Chaban, 46–65. Baden-Baden: NOMOS and Bloomsbury.
Wang, Z.P., and T. **a. 2018. The EU’s role in globalization. European Studies 1: 77.
Wang, L., et al. 2013. An evaluation of the prospects of TTIP. Modern International Relations 3: 9.
Ye, B. 2015. EU-China bilateral investment agreement prospects. International Outlook 6: 117.
Zhang, L. 2011. News media and EU-China relations. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Zhang, L. 2014. What shapes perceptions of the EU in China? Discrepancies between media representation and public perception. In Europe and Asia: Perceptions from Afar, ed. M. Holland and N. Chaban, 66–85. Baden-Baden: NOMOS and Bloomsbury.
Zhang, L. 2016b. ‘Reflexive expectations’ in EU–China relations: A media analysis approach. Journal of Common Market Studies 54 (2): 463–479.
Zhang, L. 2020. Research progress in Chinese perceptions of the EU: A critical review and methodological reflection. Asia Europe Journal 18 (1): 17–34.
Zhang, L., and Y. Yu. 2013. Chinese views of the EU: Overview of survey findings. In China and the European Union, ed. L. Dong, et al., 11–36. London: Routledge.
Zhang, L. 2013b. ‘The EU started to investigate China’s telecom products, People’s Daily, 16th May.
Zhang, H. 2016a. ‘The EU’s system authority meets challenges again’. People’s Daily, 27th October.
Zhang, X.T. 2016. Analysis of the EU’s new trade strategy and the responses. International Trade 4: 45.
Zhang, D.F., and D.H. Chong. 2013. EU member states object the EU’s imposition of taxes on imports of solar panels from China. People’s web, 28th May.
Zhou, H., Z. Liu, and Y. Fan. 2009. Chinese opinions on Europe in 2008 [2008 nian zhongguoren de ouzhou guan]. European Studies [ouzhou Yanjiu] 5: 99–155.
Zhou, M.R. 2014. TTIP and its influence on the global trade structure. Review of International Economy 1: 77.
Zhu, L.Q. 2008. Chinese perceptions of the EU and the China-Europe relationship. In China-Europe relations: Perceptions, policies and prospects, ed. D. Shambaugh, E. Sandschneider, and H. Zhou. London: Routledge.
Funding
This work was supported by “the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities” in UIBE under Grant 22QD08; and Major Project for Key Research Institute of Humanities and Social Sciences in University by Ministry of Education under Grant 22JJD810028.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Kuang, S., Song, X. Chinese representations of EU trade actorness. Comp Eur Polit 21, 668–686 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41295-023-00358-0
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41295-023-00358-0